Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • who_cares973
    FFR Player
    • Aug 2006
    • 15407

    #17041
    Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

    btw im still a judge lol was only fake ragequitting since it seemed like the cool thing that everyone was doing

    Comment

    • bmah
      shots FIRED
      Profile Moderator
      FFR Simfile Author
      Global Moderator
      • Oct 2003
      • 8448

      #17042
      Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

      Originally posted by DossarLX ODI
      I'm going to consider qqwref's and sam's notes about Metro. I do agree it had some parts that could be improved (such as the ending).

      So if you make fixes to a file, can you just send it as soon as you make the changes? Or do I have to wait until my file is put in the conditional queue list?
      Send fixes in anytime. I've already received several revisions from others.

      I'll comment on the other crap going on later... still have one more final to write.
      Last edited by bmah; 12-18-2010, 01:13 PM.

      Comment

      • MrMagic5239
        FFR Veteran
        • Feb 2007
        • 4096

        #17043
        Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

        Originally posted by Xandertrax
        Polyrhythms gogogogogogooggogo
        I dislike all of your files with the intensity of 100,000 burning suns on a cold winter day on top of a large glacier. Contradicted myself on purpose. G'day~
        ~Grand Chase Stats~
        Elesis (Knight/Spearman/Sword Master/ Savior) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4 EXP Rank 1
        Lire (Archer/Crossbowmen/Arch Ranger/Nova) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 1
        Arme (Mage/Alchemist/Warlock/Battle Mage) Lvl 80/80 MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 1
        Ronan (Spell Knight/Dragon Knight/Aegis Knight/Abyss Knight) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 1
        Lass (Thief/Assassin/Dark Assassin/Striper) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4, EXP Rank 1
        Ryan (Druid/Sentinel/Viken/Xenocider) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 1
        Amy (Dancer/Musician/Siren/Superstar) Lvl 78/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 13
        Sieghart (Gladiator/Warlord/Duelist/Prime Knight) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 1
        Jin (Fighter/Shisa/Asura/Rama) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4 EXP Rank 1
        Zero (Seeker/Wanderer) Lvl 79/80, MP Bars 4/4 EXP Rank 9
        Dio (Stygian/Drakar//Leviathan) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 1
        Rin (Caller) Lvl 77/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 32
        Rufus (Bounty Hunter/Killer/Ravager/Arbiter) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 1
        Ley (Summoner/Harbringer) lvl 79/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 21
        Asin (Desciple) Lvl 80/80, MP Bars 4/4, EXP Rank 1 (Eastern Rain Liquid Jade aquired)

        Comment

        • dore
          caveman pornstar
          FFR Simfile Author
          FFR Music Producer
          • Feb 2006
          • 6317

          #17044
          Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

          wow. I go to sleep, wake up and not much has cooled off lol

          (since there have been many other what-is-my-judging-philosophy posts)

          My ratings sorta come from a binary perspective in that I first try to decide whether yes, I think this file could be in game right now (+ and +.); or no, I think this file is not acceptable (+? and ? and -). Then I split those files up into varying levels of potential vs. current quality:

          + I think this file is good enough to go in the game as-is, even if I feel like there are improvements that could be made (which would generally be minor)
          +. I think this file is good enough to go in the game, but it either could use minor improvements (small mistakes that are noticeable but overall minor) or is stepped within its style well but is overall unappealing/nothing special/boring, etc.
          +? This file has good potential but needs work to be acceptable
          ? This file may have some potential, but needs lots and lots of work to be acceptable. Either completely overhaul the file or just try something else.
          - In order to make this file acceptable, you would have to completely redo the entire thing and it would basically not even be the same file at this point, or it's something that had so many obvious errors that I didn't have the patience to look through the whole thing.

          The thing with my style is that there is a larger gap between e.g. + and +. than there is between +. and +?, which is fine under a binary system but not so much in a linear point system. But I also feel that giving a + to some files is way too generous, which goes into a subjective territory, but I feel like it is legitimate to take off points for subjective matters to a certain extent. I can expand upon that point a little if anyone cares.
          http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IREnpHco9mw

          Comment

          • psychoangel691
            Retired Staff
            FFR Simfile Author
            • Dec 2004
            • 10438

            #17045
            Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

            Originally posted by dore
            I also feel that giving a + to some files is way too generous, which goes into a subjective territory, but I feel like it is legitimate to take off points for subjective matters to a certain extent. I can expand upon that point a little if anyone cares.
            I tend to feel giving a straight plus is too generous at times too. I wasn't trying to say that no points at all should be taken off for subjective matters but where's the line? That's what I'm getting at. If a judge rejects a file purely off of nothing but subjective things is that a correct judgement?

            I'm just trying to find a balance here so while everyone will have their opinions on certain things it wont completely cause huge differences in ratings to where people are like ?_?

            Also I'm kinda trying to find the groove here for terms of my own judging. Personally I'd look at things a little differently then most people do here but I've been trying to think like an "FFR" judge so to say but I guess there really isn't any sort of actual judging guidelines like I thought there were. I was trying to do my best to "fit in" with the other judges so to speak.
            Originally posted by Charu
            My dick is good, thank you very much. It gets love and attention no matter what <3 <3 <3
            Originally posted by DaBackpack
            also a fucking helicopter is the absolute last place I'd go to find out how big my dick is
            Originally posted by Shadow_God_10
            Dawg you don't even know. It's so fuckin' small I can use a pen cap to jack off

            Originally posted by hi19hi19
            yeah I'mma go for the Rave7 route she's just perfect, stiff on the top, thin in the middle, and has a BIG THICC END that I can just jack on all night UwU best girl

            Comment

            • customstuff
              ♥C.S. + A.M.♥
              • Nov 2006
              • 4892

              #17046
              Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

              Alright, sent my revised version of Phalanx. I really hope this is more enjoyable now. In my opinion, it is

              By the way, a good system that could work is the very first submission of a file could be judged fairly strictly, by adding opinionated judgments. Then, the authour could use that to improve the file, maybe add resubmission in the name, and then the judges could base that off of straight technicality/fun factor. Just a random thought
              Last edited by customstuff; 12-18-2010, 01:55 PM.

              Originally posted by MrMagic5239
              Placements are final, custom will not be moved to D6, just because he is good at jacks, and mediocre at just about every other FMO in the game.
              Originally posted by customstuff
              Originally posted by MrMagic5239
              welcome to D6

              start playing

              Comment

              • bmah
                shots FIRED
                Profile Moderator
                FFR Simfile Author
                Global Moderator
                • Oct 2003
                • 8448

                #17047
                Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                @MrPopadopolis: If the file wasn't accepted into the batch, it'll be marked as a resubmit for the next batch, and you'll get your results later (ie. you have to wait a while). If it was accepted into the batch, and you want to make small changes, it'll be changed right away.

                What I was saying earlier though had to do with when one is allowed to send files in the first place. I've come to understand that you cannot send any new files when submissions are closed; we're only taking in new files when submissions are open. However, you can resend a fixed file anytime.

                Comment

                • AlexDest
                  good hot
                  FFR Simfile Author
                  • Sep 2007
                  • 5309

                  #17048
                  Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                  Resubmitted some fixes for Chik Habit from yesterday.

                  Comment

                  • iironiic
                    D6 FFR Legacy Player
                    FFR Simfile Author
                    • Jan 2009
                    • 4342

                    #17049
                    Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                    Originally posted by bmah
                    Send fixes in anytime. I've already received several revisions from others.

                    I'll comment on the other crap going on later... still have one more final to write.
                    Sweet Sending Beautiful Arrhythmia with edits

                    Comment

                    • customstuff
                      ♥C.S. + A.M.♥
                      • Nov 2006
                      • 4892

                      #17050
                      Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                      I still have no idea if my file even met the conditional queue...

                      How many points would +?, +, +?, and +? be?

                      Originally posted by MrMagic5239
                      Placements are final, custom will not be moved to D6, just because he is good at jacks, and mediocre at just about every other FMO in the game.
                      Originally posted by customstuff
                      Originally posted by MrMagic5239
                      welcome to D6

                      start playing

                      Comment

                      • bmah
                        shots FIRED
                        Profile Moderator
                        FFR Simfile Author
                        Global Moderator
                        • Oct 2003
                        • 8448

                        #17051
                        Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                        Those ratings would not be even conditional...
                        I don't know the points off the top of my head though.

                        Comment

                        • Plan_Bsk81127
                          snooches
                          FFR Simfile Author
                          • Aug 2007
                          • 6420

                          #17052
                          Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                          Think 16 is conditional and 17+ is accepting.

                          custom you got 14.

                          Comment

                          • customstuff
                            ♥C.S. + A.M.♥
                            • Nov 2006
                            • 4892

                            #17053
                            Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                            Friiig, well I guess there's a file for next batch :s

                            Originally posted by MrMagic5239
                            Placements are final, custom will not be moved to D6, just because he is good at jacks, and mediocre at just about every other FMO in the game.
                            Originally posted by customstuff
                            Originally posted by MrMagic5239
                            welcome to D6

                            start playing

                            Comment

                            • bmah
                              shots FIRED
                              Profile Moderator
                              FFR Simfile Author
                              Global Moderator
                              • Oct 2003
                              • 8448

                              #17054
                              Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                              The thing is, apparently conditional files are still only reserved for offsync files, which means that the cutoff line jx set simply divides what's accepted and what's rejected. This doesn't leave room for the "grey area" in between however. I really think conditional files should have a place within the point system.

                              Comment

                              • ichliebekase
                                FFR Simfile Author
                                FFR Simfile Author
                                • May 2006
                                • 3213

                                #17055
                                Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

                                Fixing -Glorious Morning- for the next batch. I already have a bunch of new ideas for it.

                                EDIT: Oh, well already I've fixed the majority of the problems. Most of the ones mentioned were the same, some were ones that I hadn't of even known of which added well to the chart. Thanks for the help on this one, all the judges that looked at this one gave good help. Thanks kommi, Patashu, Luis, and qqwref.

                                Looking to get permission from DJ Splash [hopefully] so I can send in Flying High, because I thought it was one of my better files that I stepped for DF.
                                Last edited by ichliebekase; 12-18-2010, 02:35 PM.
                                Glorious Morning - Misc, level 48
                                We Will Fly - Dance 2, level 53
                                =.The Ocean.= - Dance 2, level 56, collab with krunkykai22
                                Garden Party - Dance, level 38

                                Comment

                                Working...