Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[Plan_Bsk81127]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

From here on out, if you dont like how the judges doing what they are supposed to do, dont waste your time submitting a file.

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Well that isn't doing anything to solve the problem. While we cannot fully eliminate subjectivity, I know there are ways to improve upon it.

[AsphyxZero]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

It's got FFR file written all over it

Define FFR file. When I think of FFR file, I think of a synthlight file. If you want to be compared to the stepping-prowess of synthlight, may God have mercy on your soul.

[bob bob]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

knew my files would get rejected, haha

Its good to get feedback on them, might resubmit 1/2

Also sending new stuff to next batch (terminal 11 easy file weeeee)

[MarioNintendo]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

knew my files would get rejected, haha

Its good to get feedback on them, might resubmit 1/2

Also sending new stuff to next batch (terminal 11 easy file weeeee)

See? That's the spirit! No need to be harsh on anyone's case after you read such a statement.

[bob bob]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

feedback=best way to improve a file

multiple peoples feedback=4x the ways to improve the file

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

oh god bob bob, you're a breath of fresh air ^v^

(note however that comments are still to a degree not fully correlated to actual ratings, which is why debates still exist)

[psychoangel691]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

They know what's fun and what isn't. From what I've seen from the judges thoughts and notes, they didn't find it fun/good.

hmm....

The Final Hour (psychoangel691) - [+.]
Playtest: Hmm, sounds a lot like The Prototype, doesn't it? Fun file, especially the 8th jump sections. (and he was labeled the strict judge lol)

The Final Hour - In the beginning you overuse the jumps. Don't really need them to every single sound.
Same goes for the section around m50 that you do the same thing in.
Other than that this is fine. Just fix up those small sections. +?

The Final Hour [Psychoangel691]

Playtesting: File was fun


K it wasn't fun. Anyways I'm done even trying to get through to anyone on here because you guys only read what you wanna read and target stupid junk. Yes mentioning subjective stuff is good but it's bad to outright reject for it.

And I never said I didn't expect to make some fixes but we're talking about every damn aspect of the chart here. That's a bit different then making some fixes. The only judges suggestions that really made a lot of sense were Carlos' and okay I can make those fixes but then I don't get past the other two judges so it doesn't matter anyway. I would have to change way too much in this file is what I was saying but apparently that wasn't understood.

[bob bob]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

oh god bob bob, you're a breath of fresh air ^v^

That what im aiming for

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

And to be frankly honest, when this happened to me in the past, I never sent the file again. If the file had to be changed into something that I wouldn't remotely agree with, I remember sadly departing with the file and making something else. Fortunately, I have a LOT of stuff to step...

[bob bob]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

just noticed-rockhill got this

-/+./+?/?

Lol, thumbs up for no ratings the same

[psychoangel691]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

And to be frankly honest, when this happened to me in the past, I never sent the file again. If the file had to be changed into something that I wouldn't remotely agree with, I remember sadly departing with the file and making something else. Fortunately, I have a LOT of stuff to step...

Exactly, I tried some of the fixes and they feel awful. I'd rather just play the chart how it is and enjoy it rather than change it have it go up on ffr and hate it.

[Plan_Bsk81127]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

People just get moody when their files dont get accepted, just seems to be the case here. You have this attitude that this is the only file you made that will ever have the chance of getting into FFR. If you dont feel like doing what the judges suggest because you feel it will ruin how you stepped the file ok, then do what bmah just said, just dont bother with that file anymore and move on to a new one. There is no point sitting here anymore and arguing so hard for one little file. Its really not worth it. There is so much to step out there, just go step something else.

[AsphyxZero]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Like I said, release this file, step another file, and send that one to FFR for the next batch.

[Detrimentalist]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

People just get moody when their files dont get accepted, just seems to be the case here.

Yeah, AJ is moody about his file not being accepted.

...o