Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread
And I never argued that, yet when I went on to try and discuss everything, you come out with a snotty comment, saying that I'm only trying to help and saying that you knew it was going to happen, when all I was doing was getting legitimate questions. It also seems that you're blind enough to notice the fact that I actually took advice from each judge who gave notes. But no, the word subjectivity makes everyone who judges ****ing cringe.
which is why I made the whole post taking apart everything bit by bit, telling people why I disagreed with and like I said before, even asked QUESTIONS in the post as to how something can be changed, but yet again, when someone asks a relevant question, they get told to go screw off.
Tell me this, do you consider yourself a good judge? If so, give me a valid reason as to why you would be considered as one. Now ask yourself this, do you consider me a good judge?
Yes, I do. You want to know why? I play the game all the time, I communicate with all of the people who play the game actively, who actually care about the fun factor of the game, not the technical perfection all the time. They talk about how what files are good and what is not. I'm able to tell the difference between entirely subjective errors and what's not, and even through the errors that the files have, I at least have the common courtesy to try and point out something nice about the file rather than completely passing it off as a file that isn't worthy. Now for your second question. Do I consider you a good judge? Your notes are in-depth, you pick your spots like everyone else and you actually give two sides of things, but your notes constantly consist of things like changing layering rather than missing notes. You don't even point out a possibly problematic section, you just tell them to change, change, change, change. I'm sitting here just pointing out the errors and showing them what can be done to improve, not trying to act as a voice that forces unwanted changes. I actually sat there and said in the first sentence of my post that I was asking questions/stating points to help, but of course, you go off saying that you knew. Just like I knew exactly how the ratings would turn for a specific file that two people [++]'d. mhm
No, but you're telling people to make changes regardless of what they have - I mean, you're pretty much telling people who have perfectly respectable files to completely restructure them. Going back to the previous batch, a file that had [+.][+.] from two other judges got completely got the can because you decided that, even though the file was "decent", you'd give it a [-] (referring to Wolf in Night, Human in Dreams). Everyone is allowed to have whatever opinion they want, but giving a rating that isn't how the file should be rated is completely unjustified.
Bold point #1: I really don't know what brings this point up other than the fact that I actually helped with the chart, yet you feel the need to take a cheap shot and bring in more babbling and BS.
Bold point #2: I don't even know why you're coordinating stuff within the game in the first place when you've been gone for who knows how long. That's my honest opinion, since you've been so kind enough to be abrasive when this entire thing could have been avoided had you actually discussed what I asked for and not made a snide comment. In my eyes, being a judge is a privilege, and not a job - if your attitude is going to be complete garbage to others, then you shouldn't serve in the community to begin with.
I'm done, don't respond, don't talk - I've lost interest in the game and the only thing I had left was stepping, but I can't even enjoy that knowing that people can't even tell the difference between objective and subjective errors. It's even more frustrating knowing that someone who I was relatively cool with has turned into a power-hungry, arrogant prick.
Peace - done with this drama, not worth staying up late in the evening to fight with people who just don't matter.
I was capable of admitting that i was subjective too. Even kayla just mentioned an example for me doing so. Also, there were times when i even stated in my notes that i was going to be subjective. Also, i don't care what you say, if Kayla's file was accepted, i bet you wouldn't even be arguing about this at all.
Anyone who states an opinion, including yourself, would think that they are partially right in some way am i wrong? Stop acting like you don't do the same damn thing.
Tell me this, do you consider yourself a good judge? If so, give me a valid reason as to why you would be considered as one. Now ask yourself this, do you consider me a good judge?
Yes, I do. You want to know why? I play the game all the time, I communicate with all of the people who play the game actively, who actually care about the fun factor of the game, not the technical perfection all the time. They talk about how what files are good and what is not. I'm able to tell the difference between entirely subjective errors and what's not, and even through the errors that the files have, I at least have the common courtesy to try and point out something nice about the file rather than completely passing it off as a file that isn't worthy. Now for your second question. Do I consider you a good judge? Your notes are in-depth, you pick your spots like everyone else and you actually give two sides of things, but your notes constantly consist of things like changing layering rather than missing notes. You don't even point out a possibly problematic section, you just tell them to change, change, change, change. I'm sitting here just pointing out the errors and showing them what can be done to improve, not trying to act as a voice that forces unwanted changes. I actually sat there and said in the first sentence of my post that I was asking questions/stating points to help, but of course, you go off saying that you knew. Just like I knew exactly how the ratings would turn for a specific file that two people [++]'d. mhm
Oh so now you're assuming that I seek perfection of files. Have you even looked at my files and see any perfection in them? I know very well that no files are perfect. I have a right to state whatever opinion i want when judging a file.
What about your damn attitude? Everytime you disagree with something, you go and bash about it especially if involves your engaged wife. I care about this site a lot more than you assumed i do and i definitely help out people when i judge a file. So what, you think that i randomly come on this site not caring for everyone else and doing whatever i want? Look at the tier point thread, I've spent so much time working on it and when i post it, people didn't like it so i waited for people to give out suggestions and i listened to them. So now, i have to spend even MORE time making a better tier point system just for the sike of the community. For the record, you can be elitist too so stop acting like you're not at times.
Bold point #2: I don't even know why you're coordinating stuff within the game in the first place when you've been gone for who knows how long. That's my honest opinion, since you've been so kind enough to be abrasive when this entire thing could have been avoided had you actually discussed what I asked for and not made a snide comment. In my eyes, being a judge is a privilege, and not a job - if your attitude is going to be complete garbage to others, then you shouldn't serve in the community to begin with.
I'm done, don't respond, don't talk - I've lost interest in the game and the only thing I had left was stepping, but I can't even enjoy that knowing that people can't even tell the difference between objective and subjective errors. It's even more frustrating knowing that someone who I was relatively cool with has turned into a power-hungry, arrogant prick.
Peace - done with this drama, not worth staying up late in the evening to fight with people who just don't matter.
Comment