Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

[DossarLX ODI]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

FMO list is finished. We just have to clean up the requirements a little bit.

Byron said that it would be released some time this week

[bob bob]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

[Darkbreezee]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

sounds good to me xD

[i love you]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

For now, I will post the Challenging requirements. I am still rechecking the VD list but once I'm done with it, that will be the next list I post. If you have any comments/suggestions, please mention them in this thread! We are human after all not robots!

1. 20031023 [1119 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 6 or fewer
(3) - 25 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

2. Amefuri Koneko [881 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

3. Attack of One Minute [500 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 75 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

4. Carol Megamix [1225 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 6 or fewer
(3) - 25 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

5. Chaoz Japan [831 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

6. Coat Czech [670 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 3 or fewer
(4) - 10 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 80 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

7. Destination Unknown [849 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

8. Famouz [392 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 3 or fewer
(3) - 10 or fewer
(2) - 40 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

9. Final Fantasy 3 Boss [781 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

10. Forsaken Neon [650 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 50 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

11. Gaussian Blur 3 [859 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

12. Ivaltek [1115 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 6 or fewer
(3) - 25 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

13. Hyper Pressure [1111 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 6 or fewer
(3) - 25 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

14. Kirby Dream Land [947 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

15. Legendary Etude [1326 Combo]
(5) - 1 or fewer
(4) - 9 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 150 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

16. Megane De Ne! [1390 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 50 or fewer
(2) - 150 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

17. Nyanyanyanyanyanyanya! [666 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

18. Over the Frail Dream [789 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 50 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

19. Ruins [877 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

20. Song of the second moon [705 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

21. Sunny Starry Carnival [930 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

22. Synaxis Symphony [706 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

23. Toru No Uta (Noise Rave Mix) [1148 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 40 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

24. {Blaze} [1372 Combo]
(5) - 1 or fewer
(4) - 9 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 150 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

25. {Rose} [1301 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 3 or fewer
(4) - 10 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

Also, it seems like that the D list got the approval by the community so I will list that as finalized!

[CammyGoesRawr]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

C List looks reasonable imo (: +1

[One Winged Angel]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

SDG to AAA seems like a really big gap for an additional TP on some of those files, but aside from that, they look gr9

Only suggestion would be to change the 10 or fewer reqs to 9 or fewer (or vice versa) just for the sake of consistency. I know the 10 or fewer req is currently used for 3/5 and SDG is 4/5 but I still think it would look nicer with one 'set' req for the ~10 good range.

[Zekramcross]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

The C list looking good. I can get some TPs from this list.

[Sweet_Feet]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

but aside from that, they look gr9

You did not just...

Anyhow, C list looks tight. I do agree with what OWA is saying about the gap from SDG to AAA (hyper pressure, ivaltek, carol megamix and 20031023)

[i love you]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

SDG to AAA seems like a really big gap for an additional TP on some of those files, but aside from that, they look gr9

Only suggestion would be to change the 10 or fewer reqs to 9 or fewer (or vice versa) just for the sake of consistency. I know the 10 or fewer req is currently used for 3/5 and SDG is 4/5 but I still think it would look nicer with one 'set' req for the ~10 good range.

Yeah, that gap definitely does seem somewhat big. I will look into that.

[i love you]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

@OWA and Sweet_Feet: It is done! Tell me if those requirements are better for those types of files. I am pretty sure this should be good now!

1. 20031023 [1119 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 6 or fewer
(3) - 25 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

2. Amefuri Koneko [881 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

3. Attack of One Minute [500 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 75 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

4. Carol Megamix [1225 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 6 or fewer
(3) - 25 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

5. Chaoz Japan [831 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

6. Coat Czech [670 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 3 or fewer
(4) - 9 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 80 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

7. Destination Unknown [849 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

8. Famouz [392 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 3 or fewer
(3) - 9 or fewer
(2) - 40 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

9. Final Fantasy 3 Boss [781 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

10. Forsaken Neon [650 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 50 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

11. Gaussian Blur 3 [859 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

12. Ivaltek [1115 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 6 or fewer
(3) - 25 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

13. Hyper Pressure [1111 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 6 or fewer
(3) - 25 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

14. Kirby Dream Land [947 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

15. Legendary Etude [1326 Combo]
(5) - 1 or fewer
(4) - 9 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 150 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

16. Megane De Ne! [1390 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 50 or fewer
(2) - 150 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

17. Nyanyanyanyanyanyanya! [666 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

18. Over the Frail Dream [789 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 50 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

19. Ruins [877 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

20. Song of the second moon [705 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

21. Sunny Starry Carnival [930 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

22. Synaxis Symphony [706 Combo]
(5) - AAA
(4) - 5 or fewer
(3) - 20 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

23. Toru No Uta (Noise Rave Mix) [1148 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 5 or fewer
(4) - 15 or fewer
(3) - 40 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

24. {Blaze} [1372 Combo]
(5) - 1 or fewer
(4) - 9 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 150 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

25. {Rose} [1301 Combo]
(6) - AAA
(5) - 3 or fewer
(4) - 9 or fewer
(3) - 30 or fewer
(2) - 100 or fewer
(1) - pass the song

[PrawnSkunk]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

(still) looks great :J

I'm majorly OCD'ing about how BF on some songs make full req. don't mind me~

[Sweet_Feet]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

The sdg requirement looks much better



..side note, what does everyone think about possibly lowering the 100 good requirements down to 80 ish?

[Frederic54]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

The C list looks quite good. Personally I would have put for Ivaltek : (6): AAA and (5): 3 or fewer, since the file is quite tricky. Also like OWA said, the gap between SDG and AAA on some files is maybe too much. And last point, why 1 or fewer for Blaze and not AAA ?

[who_cares973]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

because blaze is gay and causes tons of problems(or at least did during avmiss days)

[i love you]

Re: Completely Revised Official Tier Point System

The C list looks quite good. Personally I would have put for Ivaltek : (6): AAA and (5): 3 or fewer, since the file is quite tricky. Also like OWA said, the gap between SDG and AAA on some files is maybe too much. And last point, why 1 or fewer for Blaze and not AAA ?

I am not sure if Ivaltek should have a 6/6 as the max requirement. When I compared that file with the other files with a 6/6 as max requirement, it just does not fit the difficulty range. I will further discuss this with my leaders. As for the gap issue that OWA mentioned, I already fixed that issue in the last post silly.

As for blaze having a BF as the max requirement. I will have to ask qqwref about that since he was the one who did that requirement. I THINK it is because blaze is basically a long stream file with places that could easily make you get a good somewhere but I am not 100% sure.

EDIT: I am sure it is because that making blaze have a 5/5 requirement of a AAA is a bit harsh and making blaze have a 6/6 AAA requirement is too lenient so making it a BF would definitely make sense.

EDIT2: I was correct! That was the reason however I will let you guys vote on whether {Blaze} should have an AAA as the max requirement or a BF. I personally choose BF but I want everyones opinion about it!