-
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
After doing some planning, this is what Sprint 3 looks like:
Sprint 3
9/16/15 - 9/30/15
Dates in parentheses indicate the expected date to finish by. Completion could be earlier or slightly later.
9/22/15 Song Release
* This is basically predetermined with the 2 remaining songs; with the completion of Set 3 we have more files coming in. Silvuh informed me there are 15 accepted files out of 22, most with CQ status and 4 currently accepted.
- Prepare song release (song info, thread, FPP) - Dossar (9/21/15)
- Determine difficulties for the release - One Winged Angel (9/21/15)
Batch Search Engine
* Additions to this are currently low priority
- Define Acceptance Criteria - hi19hi19 (TBD)
- Put in years for Latest Update Field - Unassigned (TBD)
- Get notes and length for Special Batch Files - Unassigned (TBD)
- Add notes and length fields to JSONs - Dossar (TBD)
Judge Hard Song Batch
* This relies on the finalization of the judgment system. Current judges listed are tentative, and judgment should start next week
- Judgment - Phase 1 Pt 1 (Lead) - One Winged Angel (TBD)
- Judgment - Phase 1 Pt 1 (Reviewer) - Dossar (TBD)
Passed Files
* Set 2 Passed files might be assigned to Silvuh
- Judge Passed Files - Set 2 - Unassigned (TBD)
- Judge Passed Files - Set 3 - Dossar (9/19/15)
Rework Judgment System
* A rough draft of this is done and needs to be polished up. Both Silvuh and Dossar have been working on this and it will be available within the next few days
- Finalize new judgment system method - Silvuh (9/21/15)
Set 1
- Set 1 Full Notes (3rd notes) - TC_Halogen (TBD)
Set 2
- Set 2 First Half Notes (1st notes) - lurker (TBD)
- Set 2 Second Half Notes (1st notes) - psychoangel691 (TBD)
Set 3
* All Set 3 Notes are done putting aside one passed file
- Put together post for Set 3 Notes - Dossar (9/19/15)
- Determine accepted and conditionally queued files - Silvuh (9/19/15)
Web Development Opportunities
* Not related to the batch, although it might spark up some more ideas for the Batch Search Engine. Thread should be created ASAP, the scenarios given will be determined a few days after
- Create Thread Post for User Applications - Dossar (9/21/15)
- End applications - Dossar (9/25/15)
- Put together web development tasks - Dossar (9/25/15)Last edited by DossarLX ODI; 09-27-2015, 06:02 AM.Originally posted by hi19hi19Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
Batch Notes for Set 3 in September/October 2014 have been posted. The Batch Search Engine will be updated by tomorrow.Originally posted by hi19hi19Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
By the way, any questions/comments/concerns for my notes feel free to PM me. This is the first batch I've ever judged so my notes might not be as good as Silvuh's or Dossar's notes.
Honestly surprised to see Insignia get three 8's, considering the song choice I was expecting something more like 7/7/7.Last edited by gameboy42690; 09-19-2015, 07:55 PM.Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
Set 3 in September 2014 has been updated on the Batch Search Engine to reflect what files are accepted and what is Conditionally Queue'd.
Accepted, Conditional Queue, Rejected, and ResubmissionsLast edited by DossarLX ODI; 09-19-2015, 08:59 PM.Originally posted by hi19hi19Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
Why does that link only show two of my submitted files out of 4
Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
You have four files in Set 1 for September/October 2014. The notes posted were just for Set 3.Originally posted by hi19hi19Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
The scope of the conditional queue has expanded to any file that is only lightly accepted, the 1 SAP, 6.7–7.5 range. Lightly accepted files do usually receive quite a few suggestions. We think this will help create more of a conversation between steppers and judges, illuminate both sides of an issue, and hopefully broaden each other's perspectives.
However, we haven't reached a consensus on how CQ files should be handled. But do go ahead and send in fixes, because if they're acceptable, we can queue them right away.
There are a few things about the new judgment system that can be said now:
Files will be judged in small groups in chronological order (with files by the same stepper spread out), and notes will be released five files at a time. Because of this, resubmissions can be appended to the end of whichever batch is being currently judged (after this Sept-Oct batch).
Also, judgment for the next batch will start as soon as any judge has no more files in the current batch to look at, so until we get through the backlog, there will always be work open for judges to do.
So if you were among the first to submit to the 2014 Nov-Dec batch, it will be good to get any fixes in soon.
September/October 2014, Set 3
Accepted into Queue
Wonder Bullfighter ~A Barcelona cuando florece la lira~
Insignia
Galaxy in Toybox [Light]
Follow You
Rampage
Conditional Queue
Reason: Accepted by only one judge out of three
3 Year Anniversary Mix
Dark World
Over the Rave F.O.R. Remix
Summer Colours Arch
PWRPFF RAVES (one rejection + one CQ flag)
Reason: Light Acceptance (6.7 - 7.5)
Triumph
Nightfall (Original Mix)
Reason: Particular fix requested by all three judges
Gym Training Montage
65.54s: Remove this jump to go with 69.71s
89.41, 91.50s: Missing jumps to melody + kick
Azure Emotion
48.66, 48.87, 55.33, 55.54s: Unlayer these jumps
Galaxy in Toybox [Heavy]
80.64-84.96s: Structure the 32nds or try something different
Resubmissions
Get Jinxed! [Razor]
Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
o okComment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
K final fixes sent for november december 2014Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
As of 9/23/2015 10:00 PM EST the Batch Search Engine has been updated with the following:
Please let me know if I missed anything.
In other news:
The finalized judgment system will be put in place for the High FGO Special Batch the end of this week. Phase 1 of the Special Batch will be ending submissions on Saturday 11:59 PM EST and judgment will be starting next week 5 files at a time. Phase 2 will start Sunday 12:00 AM EST and stepartists can submit up to their cap again; the Special Batch will be going into October.
Users who had files moved over from a previous batch to the Special Batch can replace the submissions in the previous batch to fill in the gaps caused by these moves. The files that were moved originally can be found in this spreadsheet.Last edited by DossarLX ODI; 09-23-2015, 08:34 PM.Originally posted by hi19hi19Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
A New Judgment System Document has been put up and can be seen through the thread. Some parts of it will be revised as necessary if any other situations arise.
The New Judgment System will be used starting with the Hard Songs Batch. The September/October 2014 Batch will be the end of the old batch system.Originally posted by hi19hi19Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
I'll send fixes for PRWPFF RAVES do not throw it out
Comment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
I approve of the new judgement systemComment
-
Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]
The new judge system looks good to me. I just have one quick question. How many lead judges are reviewing each file?Comment
Flash Flash Revolution
Comment