Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[Wayward Vagabond]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Nope

[DossarLX ODI]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

10/10/2015 Update: The September/October 2014 Batch now has all sets of notes completed. The posts in the Batch Review Thread have been edited to include all three sets, as well as the supplementary notes for Set 2 and Set 3.

Currently I am only able to post the Set 1 Finalized File Results. Set 2 will be coming when Silvuh becomes available again. The Batch Search Engine will be updated with the status for Set 1 shortly, and now all three bootstrap alerts for September/October 2014 will be green. It's about time.

September/October 2014, Set 1



Accepted into Queue

Game Genie
B.B.K.K.B.K.K
Zauberkugel
Gangsters Paradise (Candyland's OG Remix)
Braum
Wheelpower & Go
Drunk Crunk Franken

Conditional Queue

Reason: Accepted by only one judge out of three

Belly Dance (Consistently Drinkin' Remix) [Standard]

Reason: Light Acceptance (6.7 - 7.5)

Lovely City
Belly Dance (Consistently Drinkin' Remix) [Heavy]
[Resubmission] Phantom of the Opera
Ongaku -kaiongaku mix-
Horizon
[Resubmission] They Kidnapped the Princess
Azul (Remix)

Reason: Particular fix requested by all three judges

DISCHARGE RUSH
59.75s: This 48th pattern should play better

** Wheelpower & Go (MarioNintendo) still earns 1 SAP, although the version from DarkZtar got a higher rating and the difficulty is too similar for a v2.

[_Zenith_]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Hype for Game Genie

[lurker]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

last batch ever finished gaddam H Y P E

[gameboy42690]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Just noticed that hi19's Spinal Fluid Explosion Girl is missing from Set 2. Was this forgotten or was the file pulled from the batch and I just had no idea it happened?

[DossarLX ODI]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

I have sent a PM to all the users who submitted to the September/October 2014 Batch.

As far as next steps forward:
- Silvuh is still organizing the Phase 1 files in the High FGO Special Batch. Once this is finished, judgment can start 5 files at a time. Depending on Silvuh's availability, a fair estimate would be 10/12/15.
- The Set 2 Finalized Results still need to be determined, although the notes are up. Silvuh needs to finish this task and depending on his availability, a fair estimate would be 10/12/15.
- Currently One Winged Angel and myself are blocked on Phase 1 judging until the organizing files task is completed. If it is completed by 10/12/15, then notes for the first 5 files could be up near the end of the week. I tentatively have 10/15/15, although keep in mind this is dependent on the organizing files task.
- The November 2014 Batch is being taken into consideration for continuation of regular batch judging (the Special Batch does not prevent the regular batches from being judged). However, this also requires the organizing of the files to be judged 5 at a time.
- Phase 2 Submissions for the High FGO Special Batch will be open until October 31st. The September/October 2015 Regular Batch is also open until October 31st.

There's been an interesting scenario brought up to me from a stepartist regarding special batches, and that will also require me to have a discussion with Silvuh. The plan is to resolve these blockers as soon as possible, preferrably within the next few days.

Just noticed that hi19's Spinal Fluid Explosion Girl is missing from Set 2. Was this forgotten or was the file pulled from the batch and I just had no idea it happened?

That file received judgments, and he requested it to be pulled out of the batch. The Batch Search Engine has been updated to account for this -- thanks for reminding me.

[XelNya]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Super happy with the notes that came out of this for the most part

Guess I gots fixus to do

[Silvuh]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

September/October 2014, Set 2



Accepted into Queue

Diamant・Spectrasplosion
miko
Guitars Suck
waltz in d-flat op. 64-1 (panic station mix)
Dandelion Sparkle!!
Guitars Still Suck
Suicide Pact
Noushou Sakuretsu Girl (Silvuh)
Xyris
Artificial Intelligence Bomb

Conditional Queue

Reason: Light Acceptance

Emotional Adventure
[Resubmission] Zephyros
The star hill

Reason: Particular fix requested by all three judges

burned down the ghost house and escaped spooks
109.79-110.06: Remove the 32nds

[Resubission] Phantasy Story -Re:Start-
21.24, 24.53s etc: Jump these 16ths to the strings, not the following 4ths

** Spinal Fluid Explosion Girl (MarioNintendo) still earns 1 SAP, although the version from Silvuh got a higher rating and the difficulty is too similar for a v2.

Resubmissions

Japan Style Breakcore - 2
[Resubmission] Miss Jackson

[M0nkeyz]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Nice feedback on desertion, I agree with most of it and I was at a time constraint when sending in my last fixes so I myself discovered a bunch of mistakes and inconsistencies later. However some notes were kind of confusing to me:

ilikexd couldn't figure the patterning earlier in the song and made like 4 notes about the same problem:

-34.908s This part doesn't have jump consistency. There are tom drums but no jumps. The jump usage that follows is really hard to understand. It doesn't seem to consistently follow drums or guitar.

-49.255s Kick drum but no jump.

-57.489s The 32nd drums were single notes before, but now they're jumps.

-60s I can't figure out the jump usage here and beyond. It seems like jumps go to the drums, but they're omitted in so many places.

I also thought this was kinda odd

-43.114s 24th is 32nd.

Looking at the wave and listening to it on lower speed I am pretty sure this is a 24th

[YoshL]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

oh shit i didn't realize gameboy already stepped drunk crunk franken

[lurker]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

oh damn first try

- 30.840: put that 1/12 before the next 4th, it's slightly delayed

there's still a bass note at 30.84 which i'm not sure if i should step

-31.2s Strange hand usage here: in groups of three the second and third sounds are much heavier than the first, so it doesn't seem reasonable that the first one is a hand while the other two are jumps.
32.39s: Missing note to kick, should anchor with the following hand

hands are based on another synth layer, could be pr'd better

- 50.118: missing note for synth

i realized the hands here didn't really belong which freed up the space a bit (this pattern doesn't look right though)

- 87.469: ouuuuch, that's a gross pattern because of the 12th note mini-jack (comes out to a 202.5 BPM 16th mini-jack mid-stream)

- 107.082: those jumps... I understand that there's two instruments fighting there, but I'd personally drop those jumps given the section previous to that had jumps for the really strong synth melody

pattern is now 432321

[Wayward Vagabond]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Silvuh I just want to say I appreciate the amount of work that you put into your notes but all you're doing is telling people why you don't like how they stepped certain and how giving them suggestions for how they can step sections to more align with your vision of how the file should be which is fine but it seems like you don't take into consideration that a lot of what you mark as wrong or should be changed was intentional.

This also kind of applies to halogen

[Wayward Vagabond]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

BTW good job guys we finally have notes for a batch from a year ago, progress!

[VisD]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Notes on the star hill, a 50-second difficulty 10 file:

Short, easy file with good pitch relevancy.

Nice easy file, the pitch relevancy really could use some work.

[psychoangel691]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Notes on the star hill, a 50-second difficulty 10 file:

Might I ask why you only pointed out my saying PR needs work when in fact two judges pointed it out? 2 out of 3 are telling you it needs work, it's likely it needs work. Because it is so short and easy there should be more attention paid to these things.

I also gave you the best rating out of the 3 judges.