Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

[Just502]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

more like auto-reject from me peace

Judge my submissions already will ya'

[skyfox_]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

still taking files?if so sendin a fix...

[buizel8888]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

WE ARE ONLY TAKING ONE SONG ABOVE 13 FOR THE PACK AS THE BOSS SONG.

We will choose which one we want during final thinking


(Just502)

Kidney Stone - Rather repetitive. An okay file though, so I guess possibly. Accepted?

Evil Sweeper Evolution - I'm sorry, this one is just too ridiculous. It's not badly stepped, its just ridiculous. Rejected

Going on Spring Wind - Swing Music is kind of obnoxious to play, but overall this file is pretty solid. Accepted?

Malicious Fingers - hmmm, the file is okay, but it's really freaking long. I will say Accept, but lets see what happens

Shounen A - I dunno about the difficulty. It's a 14 definitely in how hard the actual file is, but since its only 1:20.... hmm Accept?

Trisection - Just no. This feels much more like a kb file than a pad file. Just way too much. Rejected


(FoxX) Bridge etc v3 - Is good except the first note of m40 is a double step, as well as the first of m44, the fourth of m44, fourth of m45, the blue note before m48, and the second note of m73. I can fix those for you if you want. After that, its an Accept

[kommisar[os]]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

find me a song to be stepped and ill do it

[Just502]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltw-jMbRWJk

Pfft, tis not too bad :P

[buizel8888]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

(Just502) - Japanese file i forgot to review
1st and 3rd stops are gay but file is cool accept

[Wyde]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

So what is that now, Just502...over 20 files you've sent us? No-one else has exceeded 10 yet, I don't think. XD

----------

25.9.09

BOSS SONG CANDIDATES

-Accept The Fact-
imo most difficulty in terms of potential step density. 3rd priority.

-Evil Sweeper Evolution-
Longest of of the bunch, and is probably fatal. 4th priority.

-Going On Spring Wind-
I'd say this is the most technical/chaotic. On that note though, I do prefer it over the other two. 2nd priority.

-Shounen A-
This seems somewhat borderline to me in terms of difficulty. On that note, it doesn't seem like anything special. The intro feels particularly unimaginative, even though I can see some progression in it. It doesn't help that I'm not exactly crazy about the song itself either. 5th priority.

-YOU are You-
I still don't understand why the freeze in bar 9 was placed as an 8th. I suppose I can change that myself, and possibly make the rest of the intro a teeny bit more consistent. Otherwise, this is still my favourite of the 14+ charts. 1st priority.

THE REST

-Blue Sky (Thanatos Remix)- REJECTED
Just adding more rolls doesn't change my opinion on this.

-Death Moon- ACCEPTED
lolstreamz

-Malicious Fingers- ACCEPTED
This looks pretty good to be honest. Some jump placement seemed a bit oddly placed (in the first half mostly) but the steps follow the music well. The fact that this song can really be split in two helps to eliminate the boredom factor, but perhaps that's my inner Sonic fan speaking. :P

-Setsujou! Hyakha Ryouran- REVISE
This needs to be cut, otherwise I'm playing virtually the exact same chart twice in a row.

-The Bridge People no Longer Cross [V3]- ACCEPTED
I'll probably go with buizel on this. It's got a few problems as he's pointed out, but yes those are easily fixed. This is a 9 footer at most though.
On a side note, I desperately want to send my own oni chart for this. I'll probably send the sm. segment along with my Spit On You fix to see what the other judges think of it.

----------

[~Zero~]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

Oh yea that song i was suppose to send, i am not sending it in. Its gonna be saved for other purposes :P

Gundam do you have a cut of Crystalize Silver by Dark PHOENiX

[buizel8888]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

I need to look at this Death Moon file here. Also I agree with Wyde, YOU are you is my first priority here too, and I guess I'm not the only one Borderline on Shounan A's difficulty.

Keep sending files in this is mad coo. Submissions are closing tomorrow night at 10pm EST. You have till then to send ya stuff.


edit:
Death Moon - k cool Accept
PS I SENT MY HARD CHART TO GO ALONG WITH THAT

(Wyde) - Bridge and Spit - both Accept

[Just502]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

Wyde, erm... I took out over half the rolls in Blue Sky, I didn't add any more?

It's the hard chart that I'm resubmitting not the expert.

[buizel8888]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

Blue Sky - Agree with Wyde. This is just too long with how repetitive the file is. The roll usage is acceptable now, but still... cant you cut this somehow?

YOU are you - Still a gay song but it is better

[Wyde]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

Wyde is dumb. I'll look at the Hard chart soonish.

UPDATE: I see you replaced many of the rolls with straight up arrows, which seems fair enough. Nothing else has changed however, and neither have my thoughts on this.

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

Gundam do you have a cut of Crystalize Silver by Dark PHOENiX

No. You're gonna have to cut it from the full song by yourself. My Xoon Finale file wasn't a cut (was lazy and I forgot).

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

(Just502) A Kidney Stone
Good scoring file but nothing more. Those trills are a bit too much for pad though. Maybe/Pending.

(Just502) Evil Sweeper Evolution
Jacking wasn't the best choice. Only good for a hard file but overall this was generic and repetitive. Rejected.

(Just502) Going on Spring Wind
A lot of mis-rhythms with your gallops. You should've layered it similar to stargroup's FFR chart, at least then the layering would be consistent and musically relevant. Otherwise, file is pretty solid so I would lightly accept.

(Just502) Setsujou! Hyakka Ryouran
Why would you step this for pad, lmfao. If you're gonna make graphics for the file, at least use graphics from the anime it's from. Song dragged on and gets repetetive. Would've been better to step the TV size version. Hand placements and 32nd jump gimmicks were interesting Rejected.

(Just502) Shounen A
Enjoyed this file quite a bit. Probably your best submission I've reviewed from you Accepted.

(Just502) Trisection
Liked Buizel's file so I'm going to have to Reject.

(Just502) Malicious Fingers
Solid file but drags on. Light accept from me.

(Just502) BF2014
Some jumps were awkwardly placed. Well stepped nonetheless. Accepted

(Zarkonis) Accept the Fact
Kinda dumpy. Too many hard files in the pack so Rejected.

[buizel8888]

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

BF2014 - I really can't judge this unbiased. I was going to step this and had a file planned totally out in my head... and this file is nothing like it. I think I may just leave this one up to Wyde.