Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

**Just502** · 09-23-2009, 01:39 PM

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

Originally posted by Wyde

'sup.

----------

22.9.09

-Allegro Cantibile- REVISE
The sync drifts mainly around the first half, so try to sort out the BPMs and such. More than anything, I felt your use of rolls hurt this file more than it healed it. It was especially ridiculous to try and read/hit by the end. There seem to be inaccuracies in following the drums here and there as well as needless jump placements.
[B]

-Blue Sky (Thanatos Remix)- REJECTED
I felt the use of rolls here, despite being fairly consistent in what it follows, was inappropriate. Also I would have preferred it if you stepped the intro more accurately as opposed to just throwing in rolls. Overall I find this rather repetitive, inaccurate and not particularly interesting, and that's particularly painful especially for a chart of this length.

-Explosive- REJECTED
Freeze/forced double step combo is interesting, but awkward. Jacks would have been preferred, but even then it doesn't alleviate the feeling of this song feeling quite overstepped. The masses of double steps in the middle sections are not appreciated I'm afraid.
(Side note: it's better than the Mungyodance chart. But anyone can make it better than the Mungyodance chart.)

-Felys- REVISE
Again feels a bit overstepped, mainly in the end, but it's not too bad in this case. The only thing I didn't like was how quickly the hands came up.Sure they fit the music, but I still feel it's a tad much.

-Over the Rave- REJECTED
Jack/double step/jump placement is inexcusable.

-YOU Are You- UNCERTAIN
Intro needs a bit of tweaking; one of the freezes seems off. Otherwise, this doesn't seem too bad. BPM gimmicks threw me off a bit, but they seem to fit. I'm in two minds about allowing the use of the 24th trills, but only because they'd be a nightmare to hit at that speed. I should probably play more 14 footers in future to better assess them.

----------

Allegro Cantabile - Have you gotten the most recent .sm from buizel? I've gotten the sync fixed up on that song, and are you referring to the rolls at the start or in the chorus?

Blue Sky - Rolls are used to accent vocals, and any place with rolls should just be treated like 16th stream.

Explosive - WHY DOES EVERYONE THINK THESE ARE DOUBLE STEPS -rage-, They are full working crossovers with footswitches. The steps with the mines under them are meant for you to switch your foot. There's a video of my friend doing this song on youtube.

Felys - The hands are easy to bracket.

Over The Rave - Jacks are not doublesteps, they are once again footswitches. ex. Right foot on right arrow then left foot on down arrow, then RIGHT foot on down arrow, then left foot on the left arrow. The jumps are meant to be bracketed.

YOU are you - I'll revise the intro. Also, the 24ths aren't honestly very hard, I can FFC/FEC them without any real issue. I have like 93 on this on pad I think?

I bracket alot.

pssstttt- let me judge

**Wyde** · 09-23-2009, 03:04 PM

Re: Solar Eclipse Pad Pack