The Etterna Project

[TheNoSoMan]

Re: The Etterna Project

I wonder if this will ever be incorporated into future main Stepmania builds or will this be its own thing as a fork of the free software engine like the old sm-ssc.

[mwes]

Re: The Etterna Project

I wonder if this will ever be incorporated into future main Stepmania builds or will this be its own thing as a fork of the free software engine like the old sm-ssc.

What are you saying? This is the main build.

[TheNoSoMan]

Re: The Etterna Project

Oh, so this is part of the upcoming Stepmania 5.2? My bad. The OP was so long that I didn't bother reading all of it and skimmed parts of it.

[MinaciousGrace]

Re: The Etterna Project

Oh, so this is part of the upcoming Stepmania 5.2? My bad. The OP was so long that I didn't bother reading all of it and skimmed parts of it.

no it is not and it will never be

what mwes was hinting at is that the vanilla devs are so hopeless that this fork might as well be the official build (for 4k kb)

pad has itg and rhythm horizon so all the vanilla repo is good for now is a laugh

[MinaciousGrace]

Re: The Etterna Project

also for those wondering there are a huge amount of changes/additions upcoming which include a total rework of the profile save and replay system to facilitate an online stats tracker/leaderboard upload

its gonna be a while to get all the bugs out tho

[TheNoSoMan]

Re: The Etterna Project

no it is not and it will never be

what mwes was hinting at is that the vanilla devs are so hopeless that this fork might as well be the official build (for 4k kb)

pad has itg and rhythm horizon so all the vanilla repo is good for now is a laugh

So you're hoping that this version of stepmania is gonna be the one thing 4k and 6k players will recognize as THE Stepmania to play instead of vanilla version which changed so many things that they fucked themselves and slowed development to a crawl? Sounds like sm-ssc.

Rhythm Horizon sounds questionable but that's for another thread.

[MinaciousGrace]

Re: The Etterna Project

So you're hoping that this version of stepmania is gonna be the one thing 4k and 6k players will recognize as THE Stepmania to play instead of vanilla version which changed so many things that they fucked themselves and slowed development to a crawl? Sounds like sm-ssc.

Rhythm Horizon sounds questionable but that's for another thread.

tbh i dont know the difference between sm-ssc and sm5, and i cant speak for 6k players, but no serious 4k player plays on vanilla sm5 anymore already; there's no element of hope involved

it's either etterna or 3.95

[Wayward Vagabond]

Re: The Etterna Project

Sm-ssc became the official build iirc

[shakesoda]

Re: The Etterna Project

tbh i dont know the difference between sm-ssc and sm5, and i cant speak for 6k players, but no serious 4k player plays on vanilla sm5 anymore already; there's no element of hope involved

it's either etterna or 3.95

man, don't be like that.

[choof]

Re: The Etterna Project

man, don't be like that.

it seems you guys only get summoned when people shit talk
what's up with that

[shakesoda]

Re: The Etterna Project

it seems you guys only get summoned when people shit talk
what's up with that

nobody talks to us lol

I just had a look over here for once to see if any cool stuff happened and I see people bagging on me

edit: how long has the chord cohesion option been in etterna? I'd merge the shit out of a PR for that, it's been on the todo list for ages I just hate touching scoring code

[choof]

Re: The Etterna Project

it seems as tho you devs hate touching any code that matters

[shakesoda]

Re: The Etterna Project

it seems as tho you devs hate touching any code that matters

[MinaciousGrace]

Re: The Etterna Project

stuff

pretty sure the last thing I said was that there is an irreconcilable difference in vision/priorities/willingness to change between the two projects

it's not my job to chase after you and suggest pull requests you might be interested in we're wayyyy past that

if you don't get feedback on anything it's probably because people feel like you don't respect their input /shrug

ps. seriously you guys could quintuple fps by cherry picking like 5 of widghets commits but kyz would prolly revert them because buttmad

[shakesoda]

Re: The Etterna Project

pretty sure the last thing I said was that there is an irreconcilable difference in vision/priorities/willingness to change between the two projects

it's not my job to chase after you and suggest pull requests you might be interested in we're wayyyy past that

if you don't get feedback on anything it's probably because people feel like you don't respect their input /shrug

ps. seriously you guys could quintuple fps by cherry picking like 5 of widghets commits but kyz would prolly revert them because buttmad

I don't care if your vision for the project is not reconcilable with upstream, that's fine (I am 100% okay with people forking for their own interests), but you can leave bitching about us all the time out of it. I don't spend my time bagging on Etterna all over forums and I'd appreciate at least enough respect from you to do the same.

I don't know what I did to make you think I don't respect people's feedback though (unless it was via inaction, in which case I guess I apologize for not spending all my time on stepmania?) & kyz doesn't even have commit access anymore since months ago.