Harry Potter 5

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • hoochan
    woah shrooms
    • Nov 2005
    • 3838

    #1

    Harry Potter 5

    This movie sucked. It was one of the biggest disappointments in my whole summer. The other one would be Spiderman 3.

    List of reasons:

    SPOILER ALERT:
    Things that shouldn't have been left out or things that were just stupid.

    1. No Quidditch
    2. Harry is not supposed to be sad and a pus.. HE SHOULD BE ANGRY!!
    3. No Quidditch
    4. No Screaming Portrait, wtf, I was excited to see her.
    5. Barely any scenes with kreacher, when he is actually VERY important
    6. No letter to Petunia saying "REMEMBER MY LAST!!"
    7. No Prefects
    8. What's up with Voldemort at the train station....in a suit...gay.
    9. NO LUNA ON THE TRAIN!!!
    A. NO Quibbler...I think this is the biggest problem with the movie because they publish his story in the quibbler later in the book, but i guess thats not important either since Rita Skeeter wasn't in the movie either. (Valentine's Day)
    B. They did no justice to Luna, they didn't show her radish earrings or butter beer necklace.
    10. No Sorting Hat song, which is a very important peek into whats to come.
    11. Doby doesn't find the room for requirement
    12. Since when is Filch comic relief?
    13. The people in the Order are passed over so quickly, along with the talk about what the Order of the Phoenix is. They could've taken more time for that, it is the title of the movie, not Dolores Umbridge Takes over Hogwarts.
    14. No Quidditch
    15. No Weasley is Our King song
    16. The Whole gawrp was just kinda weird...like Hagrid really didn't seem to care about gawrp that much.
    17. Occulmency (sp?) Came later in the movie and was like 2, 2 minute scenes.
    18. The young james potter scene was poorly done and confusing.
    19. Harry doesn't go to the fire place to see if sirius is there and gets intercepted by kreacher when he sees sirius dieing
    20. The kids of the D.A. look like pussies, they don't even fight in the Department of Mysteries!!! WHAT DID THEY TRAIN FOR!?!??!!
    21. No Quidditch
    22. No St. Mungos
    23. No seeing Neville's parents in the hospital
    24. No Mundungus
    25. Didn't say anything about harry's neighbor being a squib.
    26. Cho's best friend wasn't in the movie at all, therefore, SNEAK was not on anyone's forehead.
    27. Nothing is ever said how the prophecy could've been about Neville and not Harry.

    more to come.......
    Last edited by hoochan; 07-12-2007, 06:02 PM.
  • Intrastat
    FFR Player
    • Feb 2006
    • 97

    #2
    Re: Harry Potter 5

    Agreed. It suffers from the same list of ailments that plague the other movies. Too short, too funny and absolutely no character development. It's as if they (the scriptors) expect fans to accept it because they all know the background stories of everyone in the novels, but they fail to realize that the novels' film counterparts need to be fleshed out similarly, because they aren't just carbon copies.

    That aside, the ending duel, though visually epic, would have been better had it been more than 10 seconds.

    Comment

    • phe0nixblade
      Praise the sun mofo
      • Sep 2005
      • 4281

      #3
      Re: Harry Potter 5

      My friends pissed because of things that says. xD

      Comment

      • AriesMalvis
        FFR Player
        • Dec 2006
        • 1345

        #4
        Re: Harry Potter 5

        yea...in every movie they leave out so much
        movies never do the books justice when it comes to hp
        one thing i disliked thruout the series was no peeves
        and i still don't like whoever did the casting for this one

        Comment

        • Denzin
          FFR Player
          • May 2006
          • 4

          #5
          Re: Harry Potter 5

          I didn't read the book of it and found it very easy to understand what was going on. No character development? Harry went from being all alone and angry with everyone to realizing friends are important after all.

          Also, with your complaint about: "18. The young james potter scene was poorly done and confusing." That's just ridiculous. How could you not know what was going on? If you didn't know, you shouldn't have even been granted permission to see that movie.

          Comment

          • hoochan
            woah shrooms
            • Nov 2005
            • 3838

            #6
            Re: Harry Potter 5

            Originally posted by Denzin
            I didn't read the book of it and found it very easy to understand what was going on. No character development? Harry went from being all alone and angry with everyone to realizing friends are important after all.

            Also, with your complaint about: "18. The young james potter scene was poorly done and confusing." That's just ridiculous. How could you not know what was going on? If you didn't know, you shouldn't have even been granted permission to see that movie.
            You don't have any room to speak because you didn't read the book so you can't even begin to comprehend half of the things we're talking about.

            Comment

            • shadowraikiri
              FFR Player
              • Aug 2006
              • 269

              #7
              Re: Harry Potter 5

              i saw it today seeing it on sunday again i didnt like it but im seeing it with my friends so i have to watch it over again. they ruined hp with this one...
              MUST SEND ANGRY LETTER TO DIRECTOR
              §ĦλđШŘλΐķĭřĩ™
              THIS IS TRADEMARKED

              cant copy this stuff beezy.

              Comment

              • Xception704
                FFR Veteran
                • Jul 2006
                • 3984

                #8
                Re: Harry Potter 5

                Wow. It's already out for you guys? It's not out until like the 15th/16th in the States I believe.

                You couldn't have put spoiler tags around that? =\

                Comment

                • hoochan
                  woah shrooms
                  • Nov 2005
                  • 3838

                  #9
                  Re: Harry Potter 5

                  Sorry about that XD It came out yesterday in the States :/

                  Comment

                  • customstuff
                    ♥C.S. + A.M.♥
                    • Nov 2006
                    • 4892

                    #10
                    Re: Harry Potter 5

                    You should add no quidditch...

                    Originally posted by MrMagic5239
                    Placements are final, custom will not be moved to D6, just because he is good at jacks, and mediocre at just about every other FMO in the game.
                    Originally posted by customstuff
                    Originally posted by MrMagic5239
                    welcome to D6

                    start playing

                    Comment

                    • Yellowhappysun
                      FFR Veteran
                      • Apr 2005
                      • 64

                      #11
                      Re: Harry Potter 5

                      so so disappointing.



                      AAA's=85.

                      YES.

                      Comment

                      • hoochan
                        woah shrooms
                        • Nov 2005
                        • 3838

                        #12
                        Re: Harry Potter 5

                        Originally posted by customstuff
                        You should add no quidditch...
                        Lmfao

                        Comment

                        • tsugomaru
                          FFR Player
                          • Aug 2004
                          • 3962

                          #13
                          Re: Harry Potter 5

                          You know, things that worked well in a 700 page book may not always work well in a two hour movie.

                          AND, if everything in the movie was the same in the book, why watch the movie?

                          ~Tsugomaru
                          Originally posted by Hiluluk
                          WHEN do you think people die...?
                          When their heart is pierced by a bullet from a pistol...? No.
                          When they succumb to an incurable disease...? No.
                          When they drink soup made with a poisonous mushroom...? NO!!!
                          IT'S WHEN A PERSON IS FORGOTTEN...!!!

                          Comment

                          • iamchrisb7
                            FFR Player
                            • Aug 2006
                            • 7

                            #14
                            Re: Harry Potter 5

                            I thought they did a really good job (the best they probably could have) turning an 800 page book into 2 hours. If you look pass the stuff they left out, it was actually a really good movie.

                            Comment

                            • lightdarkness
                              Summer!!
                              • Jul 2003
                              • 11308

                              #15
                              Re: Harry Potter 5

                              I thought it was amazing and the best movie yet...

                              You can't expect the movies to be exactly the same as the book... they are DIFFERENT... so, don't complain

                              Comment

                              Working...