FFR Community Pack 3

[kommisar]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

midare would be unproud...................................

[flash dualist]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

I'll be fine playing any files on any patterns on this pack as long as they are not dumps.

[Korygon]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

k

Files I would reject:
(bmah) EXTREMA PT.2
(Icyworld) Liberi Fatali

Files that are borderline reject:
Everything else your files all suck
(seriously)

[Korygon]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

Though if the song choices were better, this would be a pretty good pack. Most of the files here have the potential to be fun

[bmah]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

is my file really that bad

if it's something that can be fixed quickly I can probably do it

otherwise, I'm too busy to make a new file within this pack's timeframe

[gnr61]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

no its awsum

sent this to kommi but i might as well keep up to date here, based on files i got from the beta

A Showcage - mediocre at best??? no i think
Wolf in Sheep's Clothing - worst possible genre (bias alert but cmon we're not 13), so long, bad sync, difficulty spikes, no
Amaryllis V2 - neat yes
Arcadian - best file ever yes
Artificial Intelligence Bomb - way overdone and would benefit from :freeze-length theory: but hella potential and solidly fun yes
Burn! Bobonga! - the secret to stepping dull non-dynamic vgm is not to layer every sound. it's to not step it, no [edit: apparently this is an index file so I Abstain from judgment]
Clione - GENIUS FILE wtf; some long freezes could be changed for PR, beginning roll seems backwards, and 16ths are suspect but i'm not wearing headphones. also copypasta of the slow part at the end is bothersome, i'd either spruce it up or cut (ending seems too long a comedown from the sick climax). wont ever be played because of longsong stigma but this is good yes
Cocaine Voltron - if ur gonna step this stuff, do oit like this. meaningful jumps/patterns, rly fun bursts, yes
Colibri - LOL nice try, 'Niala.' quite fun, yes
Computer Music - yea every one of ur files is exactly like this but i like them so yes

so far p solid pack :>

[Patashu]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

these files taste TERRIBLE. take them out of my sight
\

[kommisar]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

looooooooooooooooooooooooool

[flash dualist]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

lol! Give these files a chance!

[Korygon]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

Every file is perfect and even the worst songs make amazing stepfiles

[FFR4EVA_00]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

a showcage - 6/10
a wolf in sheep's clothing - 0/10
amaryllis - 5/10
arcadian - 8.5/10
artificial intelligence bomb - 3/10
burn! bobonga! - 5.5/10
clione remix - 2.5/10
cocaine voltron - 6/10
colibri - 6/10
computer music - 5/10
crescendo - 7/10
croqel part ii - 2/10
disconnected hazard easy - 3/10
disconnected hazard hard - 3/10
do back burn - 5/10
doorbellsplosion - 4.5/10
enraptured soulz beginner - 5/10 (fix dat 32nd stream)
enraptured soulz hard - 4/10
extreme pt. 2 - 4.5/10
fast asleep - 6/10
innocence - 8/10
intermission - yes
red - 2/10
the island part ii - 6/10
utopia - 1/10

so far

hiyayaka ice - 5/10
in love with you - 4/10
liberi fatali - 3/10
mental meltdown - 6.5/10
witchcraft - 4.5/10

[sakura080789]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

who stepped Enraptured Soulz?

[Niala]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

Yay, my file isn't being completely discredited for the first time ever. :3

Also, gnr, who do you think I am? XD I don't have any alts, just me. :P

[gnr61]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

lol lurker

@niala given kommi's propensity for making files under different names (including for other people) and the fact that it is pretty much -exactly- his style my guess right now is he made it :3 :P

i would of course have to see som eof your past files to make any firm judgment (not that it really matters anyway), but mostly its cuz i've never heard of you

[Niala]

Re: FFR Community Pack 3

I have a couple of files on DF's engine, so maybe check there. Other than that, I don't submit to packs often, and when I do they usually get rejected... But, yeah, I did the chart all on my own.