Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

[trumaestro]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

send better sims, pack takes less time to complete.

[ferrari93]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

this pack

ps pull my files

[rshadow8888]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

and there goes the pack for reals

[kommisar[os]]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

it's fucking rshadow

[buizel8888]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

Oh **** where

[randomdragoon]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

I quit stepmania for a bit and then I come back and this pack progress seems to be exactly the same as before

"no famous artists" and "strict judging" don't mix

[Patashu]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

is it just me or did the number of accepted files go down from 6 to 4?

guys I think you should tutor your submitters

send them to stepmania boot camp, don't let them out until they produce quality

[xingyguy]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

is it just me or did the number of accepted files go down from 6 to 4?

guys I think you should tutor your submitters

send them to stepmania boot camp, don't let them out until they produce quality

One of the simfile makers (Ferrari93) asked for his files to be removed from the pack. Don't ask me why.

[trumaestro]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

I think at this point we've pretty much proven the inevitable.
We should probably make our reviews public. It'd be more of a convenience to the stepper, allowing them to know what to fix without having to personally ask a judge.

People are way more willing to fix files if they know what to fix and can easily ask for clarification. Making our reviews public will probably help. /lastditchefforttosavethepack

[Patashu]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

wait you weren't giving feedback to the simfile authors

looooooooool.

[trumaestro]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

i know i was for the first bunch of files i judged, but then dragoonhead said that we should have a private forum to post reviews in.

i protested. dh was all ya w/e
all the reviews are in a private board on sandshrewhero; admin has to let you view the board. currently, if a step author wants to see their review, they have to ask a judge to copypaste the thread for that file.

more of a hassle than it's worth tbh, and not just for judges. i'll probably crosspost my reviews from now on.

[Patashu]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

why would you do that

[trumaestro]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

To give step authors something they can freely ask questions about. They don't learn anything if they don't ask and don't know what they can do to improve.

Besides, most of them are probably too lazy to send any judge a pm for reviews.

[dragoonhead]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

So i think this is a good idea to put reviews for a file here in FFR
If you want the reviews,just send me a PM or a message here

[Patashu]

Re: Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

hey, I want a review for my simfile 'Through the Fire and Flames'

I still can't believe you rejected it :<