Touhou Pad Pack II

[TrickMasterMint]

Re: Touhou Pad Pack II

I was going to remove that, actually.

I didn't say the songlist was final, did I?

Fair enough. So why is Fascination Marisa not allowed?

[TrickMasterMint]

Re: Touhou Pad Pack II

Actually, on second thought I might just scrap the list altogether and start anew. I've been far too lenient.

What kind of criteria are you looking for at this point? I mean, if you're going to start scraping things left and right, how are you going to have a pack at all?

[Xiaounlimited]

Re: Touhou Pad Pack II

FaxX has its own good charts. Marisa has its own good charts. Smashing them up and stepping it does not mix the best of both worlds. Candy Galy is a good song, but Candy Gossun ended up being an overstepped pad dump.

Honestly, you could be doing much better files with your time than crapping out mashup songs like those.

Unless you can prove me wrong with an !! OMG AMAZING !! chart for Faxmarisa, I'd rather just play charts for either original song.

[edit]
Concerning the above post:
For one, I have MULTITUDES of entries still waiting to be judged. Scrapping the current list (which is primarily me anyway) wouldn't destroy the pack.

I do have a basic criteria I use for judging files (which I don't feel like outlining right now; maybe later), but that kind of stretched and vanished at points. When I'm running the project and take the brunt of the responses, I find it hard to say "no" at times. If you look at my judging for ER where I'm in the background, I'm much more strict and produce much better results as a judge.

I feel I should scrap and re-evaluate where everything stands. Nothing at this point is final. This project has barely left the ground. I'm not content with the quality of TPP1, and if this sees the light of completion I don't want it to go down the ****ter.

[TrickMasterMint]

Re: Touhou Pad Pack II

Unless you can prove me wrong with an !! OMG AMAZING !! chart for Faxmarisa, I'd rather just play charts for either original song.

I made Fascination Marisa. If anyone can make a good chart for it, it's me.

Concerning the above post:
For one, I have MULTITUDES of entries still waiting to be judged. Scrapping the current list (which is primarily me anyway) wouldn't destroy the pack.

I do have a basic criteria I use for judging files (which I don't feel like outlining right now; maybe later), but that kind of stretched and vanished at points. When I'm running the project and take the brunt of the responses, I find it hard to say "no" at times. If you look at my judging for ER where I'm in the background, I'm much more strict and produce much better results as a judge.

I feel I should scrap and re-evaluate where everything stands. Nothing at this point is final. This project has barely left the ground. I'm not content with the quality of TPP1, and if this sees the light of completion I don't want it to go down the ****ter.

Well, if you want good files, then you'll need to find good simfile artists. Have everyone who wants to be a part of it submit a file as a test, and let it be the decider of whether or not they are good enough to be a part of the pack. Pretty simple, wouldn't you say?

[ddr_f4n]

Re: Touhou Pad Pack II

Well if you're going to scrap everything and start anew with new judges and such, might as well make a new thread for it, no?

Touhou Pad Pack 2 revival thread.

[ddr_f4n]

Re: Touhou Pad Pack II

Sorry Xiao, but looking at how this pack is going right now, I'm moving to Mint's Touhou pad pack. I'm most likely going to move most of my files submitted here to that pack since it's most likely to be much more popular than this one.

I'll keep the files that are over 2:10 here though.