Criticism

[Charu]

Re: Criticism

Maybe.

[SM MaxX]

Re: Criticism

5 am and tired but hey I can throw in some thoughts I guess.

Good or bad, I try and take any criticism I get and learn whatever I can from it.

While I definitely don't condone nonconstructive criticism as the "this shit sucks" category, some people react negatively to almost any criticism thrown their way and ignore any advice given even when it's constructive. I guess in this sense I would prefer detailed criticism as well as the person receiving said criticism to have a level head about it even if it may seem to come off as negative (for all you know it might just be you taking it the wrong way than the criticizer meant). Work together and all that.

[stargroup100]

Re: Criticism

I thought the point of constructive criticism was to offer insight. If there's nothing to gain then it's not constructive.

I also think how insightful a criticism is is also a gradient. A particular critique is neither insightful nor not insightful (absolutely speaking), but there is a measure of how insightful it is.