I geuss its my undetailed review Kommisar-I actually liked TMNT and Bomber jet(shouldnt this be a 12? because it's a 13?) alot even though TMNT lacks graphics witch me or someone else will most likely end up doing.Champion cynthia as a song kinda ends to fast for me....and some of the long 12th jacks at 202 bpm were annoying.team rocket hideout was a fun easy file but it felt just a little too long and doesn't have graphics,so you know what happens there.Dashoe- I didn't like the opening them to Mario and luigi because the song felt just plain boreing, but thats my opinion.
Oh yeah here is my concept of the banner.I know its a little big but thats so you guys can check it out better.
I really want to hear what everyone has to say....Although I might do another.
problem with old video games music is that to make it longer you have to repeat it again. sweet to see you like some of my files i could make cynthia easier if you want
ps resize that banner and its perfect
Last edited by kommisar[os]; 11-14-2007, 07:31 AM.
That's what a good banner for this pack will look like.
Better than I expected.
ps if you can don't put saria or whoever that girl is in there, she's minor, put pikachu in there instead or something. also, it's appropriate to feature mario, but there's a bit too much of him when you look at the banner as a whole (3 times? how bout 2?). how could you forget yoshi lmao
Last edited by stargroup100; 11-14-2007, 10:25 PM.
Rhythm Simulation Guide
Comments, criticism, suggestions, contributions, etc. are all welcome.
The hell...yeah I forgot he's capcom aw ****.Good thing I saved the PSD like a smart person.
Yeah Just replace Megaman with a Pokemon Icon. Still, I will say it again, godly banner, lol. lol, nevermind i see mewtwo. replace megaman with samus
Reviews from me.
I played all the files that been sent already to me. Here is my opinion
1.TMNT Climatic Battle-I thought it was really fun. Challenging to. To me, looks like it can be accpeted. I'm gonna make the grafxs for this one.
2. Champion Cythia-Song was way too short. Some of the jacks were annyoing as well.
3. Bomber Jet-Again I like this one. Fun steps, and song was cool. I recommond you make a different bg for it though. If you can't, we'll make one for ya.
4. Team Rocket Hideout-My fav. out of Kommisar's files. This one was fun...but I HIGHLY recommend you shorten the song just a bit. I didn't mind but It felt like to me it was never going to end. Anyway, it was good.
5. Title theme from Partners in Time-generally the steps made sense...but the song and file was just too plain and boring. Try to find a better song to step.
6. Blue Resort-cool song, but soem of your patterns weren't good. Also, you didn't follow the pitch relevency. If you want it to get accepted, I redo the whole file all over agin.
7. Planet Colors-Again, great song but steps not so great. Seems to me that some of the notes were misplace.
ALL THESE SONG HAVEN'T BEEN ACCEPTED OR REJECTED YET. STILL WAITING ON OTHER JUDGES OPINIONS. ---If any of the simfile artist want a better explanation and how they can make there file better, just PM me or anyother of the judges that post their reviews. I updated the first page so don't forget to check it out.
No offense, but Andy is a bit minor. Maybe toss him in if you really want, but generally, most characters from SSBM and a few others (such as Snake) best represent Nintendo.
Good choice. ^_^
Too many Marios however. Replace them with other characters like Samus (a must for the banner), Capitan Falcon, Fox & Meta Knight. ^_^
Comment