Pack ratings

[Gellenduo]

Re: Pack ratings

@GD: I was actually hoping that people would realize that these ratings are subjective since no one has mentioned anything about objectivity.

Everyone has their taste, yes, but all these ratings are basically implying that SM in general has taken a wrong turn by turning away from elitism as opposed to actually sticking with it. If we all kept the established "elitist standard" of what makes a good file to appeal to the small inner circle instead of the broad community, what do you think happens when all the elite-clique simfile authors all of a sudden stop playing? I'll leave that question for you to think about, if we had not abandoned the elitism shenanigans.

You make it sound as if everyone are responisble for the survival of the community.

But yeah, I'm also gonna stop here because I didn't make this thread to fish for drama.

[lnick]

Re: Pack ratings

I knew this was a bad idea from the start.

except it isn't a bad idea

suck my cock dude

[TheNoSoMan]

Re: Pack ratings

When I rate a pack, it really depends on how I look at it. I'll state random opinions

I don't like rfpack but I like dark chancellors because of music (and probably the name). I like LCP 3 over FFRCP3 because of music and fun files. I like xoon5 over xoon4 because of fun files. And so on.

People have terrible excuses for rating things. And then drama starts because of differing opinions. It happens all the time.

[Andrew Mitchell]

Re: Pack ratings

comunity keyboard megapack 1 - 10/10
super meat boy - 10/10

[ddr_f4n]

Re: Pack ratings

Anything touhou-related = 9/9

[xferrarix]

Re: Pack ratings

eh, i don't think this is the best way to review anything but

odipack: 9/10
odipack2: 9/10
dcp: 7.5/10
xoon 5: 8/10
lcp1-3: 7~9/10 (balanced around there, they arent all the same)

[Ziergdsx18]

Re: Pack ratings

Ratings: bs/10

[Zon Fire]

Re: Pack ratings

nima/wooke

[ca25nada]

Re: Pack ratings

Single Packs 10−|X| / 10
Solo Packs 10 / 10

There's no pack where I played through all the files so I don't really have anything to say about a specific pack.

[lnick]

Re: Pack ratings

i like how people are still grading using scores when they could just be expressing themselves with, you know, words

[leonid]

Re: Pack ratings

i like how people are still grading using scores when they could just be expressing themselves with, you know, words

Super Meat Boy Keyboard Pack : Ten/Ten

[AlexDest]

Re: Pack ratings

until the most lenient, modern day laxness.

in 2-3 years those packs will have high ratings and ~*PoPuLAriTy*~

[Victorique]

Re: Pack ratings

xoon 5, LCP 2,3 Are really fun, odi pack 2, and the new FFR packs too. I got a bit bored of the old packs :P

[Ziergdsx18]

Re: Pack ratings

in 2-3 years those packs will have high ratings and ~*PoPuLAriTy*~

[lnick]

Re: Pack ratings

Super Meat Boy Keyboard Pack : Ten/Ten

so clever wew