Edit Comments

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • DragonIIDX
    Not dragon, but dinosaur
    • Aug 2008
    • 916

    #1

    Edit Comments

    Since we can edit our posts in the forums, why not be able to edit profile comments too? Not just for profile comments, but also for random thoughts, replays, videos, photos, etc. IF this is even possible of course...

    EDIT: Not just for our personal profiles, but also if you post a comment on other people's profiles and stuff too.
    Last edited by DragonIIDX; 05-7-2013, 07:44 PM.


    Originally posted by clasko1000
    banned for having an affair with peach
    Originally posted by dAnceguy117
    d-guy and d-guy skype pals 10/15/13
    Simfiles Updated 11/30/13
  • MarioNintendo
    Expect delays.
    FFR Simfile Author
    FFR Music Producer
    • Mar 2008
    • 4177

    #2
    Re: Edit Comments

    The way I see it, comments should not be editable. You lose that sort of authenticity that old old comments that should not be tormented have. Besides, where else other than Facebook (limited feature) can you edit comments?

    And inthe end, I think that's a feature not many people will end up using.

    Comment

    • foxfire667
      The FFRchiver
      FFR Music Producer
      • Jun 2009
      • 2169

      #3
      Re: Edit Comments

      Originally posted by MarioNintendo
      And inthe end, I think that's a feature not many people will end up using.
      I don't know about that, having the ability to edit a comment seems like it would be a useful feature. As it stands now, if you screw up when you post something, you really can't do anything about it, except for perhaps posting another comment making the correction (and asking for them to ignore what you wrote before). Unless it is your own profile, you cannot delete your comments either, so you are sort of forced to post multiple times and unnecessarily clutter people's profiles, instead of just making a quick edit.

      I wouldn't think this feature would be as necessary if we had the ability to delete comments we made, and just repost them again with the edit(s) appended. Since we cannot do that though, I wouldn't mind seeing some sort of quick edit feature.
      SM pack archiver | 1.5 Billion Club | Etterna Online: [Register]

      Comment

      • DragonIIDX
        Not dragon, but dinosaur
        • Aug 2008
        • 916

        #4
        Re: Edit Comments

        Pretty much what foxfire said is a more detailed explanation of why I would want it so thanks for the support. And on Final Fantasy Shrine Forums; the other site I'm active on, you can edit your comments on other people's profiles, so other sites besides facebook have the edit feature too. Backloggery also lets you edit your comments on other's profiles.
        Last edited by DragonIIDX; 05-7-2013, 11:10 PM. Reason: added moar info


        Originally posted by clasko1000
        banned for having an affair with peach
        Originally posted by dAnceguy117
        d-guy and d-guy skype pals 10/15/13
        Simfiles Updated 11/30/13

        Comment

        • DotKritic
          Forum User
          • Jun 2009
          • 2974

          #5
          Re: Edit Comments

          Five days late, but if it included "edited" after editing.

          FFR Member Since December 17th, 2004
          Save 50% on Codecademy Plus, Pro, or Pro Student

          Comment

          • DragonIIDX
            Not dragon, but dinosaur
            • Aug 2008
            • 916

            #6
            Re: Edit Comments

            Well, seeing as it hasn't happened yet, it's not too late to add on to this feature. :P


            Originally posted by clasko1000
            banned for having an affair with peach
            Originally posted by dAnceguy117
            d-guy and d-guy skype pals 10/15/13
            Simfiles Updated 11/30/13

            Comment

            Working...