wiinter dream [9 or 10]

[rayword45]

wiinter dream features little harder then many 9s. This also questions if other songs like DOAS should be a 10.

So let's compare.

wiinter dream and Dimensions of a Square are incredibly similar in terms of difficulty, featuring lots of 24th gallops with jumps placed in. Although wiinter dream is streamier and may prove slightly more difficult for some, the NPS and patterns are similar enough to justify the same rating (along with other songs possibly such as Nanairopanda)

I personally think wiinter dream could pass as a 9, but with deflation of ratings happening WAY too swiftly I say we bump up similar songs.

[bmah]

Re: wiinter dream [9 or 10]

This is the only thread I've found so far that has yet to be answered.

I think this song can go either way. People who rate this a 10 will definitely cite the 24ths at the end, especially the 24th trill at the last stretch of the stream. There is also a 24th galloping section halfway through the song that may trip some people up. Finally, there are a few bursts that may or may not be problematic for some. So I see why some people might rate this a 10.

On the other hand, the song isn't terribly fast, so I don't find these "tricky patterns" too difficult at the provided bpm.

Can go either way. I'm indifferent to this one.

[rayword45]

Re: wiinter dream [9 or 10]

This one was a bit different. I feel like this COULD be a clear-cut 10, but many other songs (DOAS, Amefuri Koneko, Ruins) also feature difficult 24th patterns.