Old replays not working

[Stewie7Griffin]

I'm certain this question has been asked before, but I did some searching and found nothing. I was wondering why my old replays don't work. When I choose "Play with my settings" no arrows are hit, they're just all misses. But if I choose "Play with replay settings" then no arrows show up at all, just the song.

I would love to watch some of my old replays, if anybody could help that'd be great.

Thanks!

P.S. The date on the replay is 1/5/11 if that helps in diagnosing version issues.