I'm not perfect either, only giving my 2 cents ;)

Actually I did alot of files before... Only I will really not mention them since they were just bajfkab Yeah. And I've heard of those tactics before but tbh, I can never really work with that, so I just keep on listening to the song over and over, really. And yeah that's true, perhaps what I think is a good song might be, well, flawed lol

Hey hey there, don't you worry. :) What I commented wasn't an in-depth review. Is that your first file or so? You have tons of potential! Still, for example, try to slow down the song in the editor while play testing it and try to notice when your rhythms don't fit the real notes. You have this issue a bit in your chart. ;P Also, song choice pretty much determines 40% of the final grade no matter who judges the song anyway ;)

Well, thanks for the critique XD I'm still a rather bad stepper.

Overall I'd give it 7 out of 10 if I were a judge, which I'm hopefully not :D

Starting at 1:17 a few rhythms are flawed (there should be 16ths). Also some jump placements seemed pretty random. Finally, that remix blows xP

The dl link to the simfile I think is in the "Test my simfile" thread, though it's posted by my main, NatsumiTheLucario (Yeah I made another alt. dealwithit.jpg)