High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Collapse
X
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Alternatively, you could just give the tests a higher ceiling, or invent even higher-level tests. The LSAT is one example. The MAT is another.I've read this before. And I guess I have to agree, but I feel like making it randomized would just be a leeway for more corrupt admissions policies. They would randomly select maybe half of the students, and then admit all of the people to fit racial quotas, legacies, and other ridiculous hooks.
I don't think you should be judged at all by your interview, and this is coming from someone who is very good at interviews. They select for expertise in body language, character of voice, and rehearsal of interview questions. If they were a major factor, helicopter parents would just start enrolling their children in Theater and Acting classes.
Essays as well are victim to this. CIf it were more like the GRE's Analytical Writing section, I suppose it would be worthwhile to weight them more--but it's currently not, and essays are victim to even more cultural variables than the infamous verbal analogy section of the SAT was.Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Eh, well I heard the complete opposite (at least the first semester at the new school ). Plus, I don't think it's currently worth it to transfer away from a department that is familiar with me (good way to get research and recommendations for grad schools).Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
I've already gotten accepted to UT Dallas, UT Arlington, TCU, Texas Tech, and North Texas, but if I can't get enough money to go to TCU, I'm probably just going to UTD for a year and then transferring to TechComment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Hopefully I'll be accepted RD into Wharton, or at least to one of HYPI predict at least one or two Ivies for you... I'd be really surprised if you got universally canned. Out of everyone I know with similar profiles to yours, I only know of one that got universally canned and they STILL got into Cornell. So, don't fret too much! "Too big to fail" is probably applicable here (don't get me started on firms though...)
Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Interviews aren't massively important to undergrad admissions because they're really just opportunities to get to know more about the school (and to ensure that the student has a pulse and isn't a clear misfit for the school). I had an absolutely HORRIBLE Yale/Tufts interview and still got in fine. Not everyone gets an interview, either, due to availability/distance constraints (that, and not all interviewers are sound). Interviewing seems to matter more for jobs, where an employer needs to see whether or not you're the type of person they want to spend 40+ hours a week with on a team.Alternatively, you could just give the tests a higher ceiling, or invent even higher-level tests. The LSAT is one example. The MAT is another.
I don't think you should be judged at all by your interview, and this is coming from someone who is very good at interviews. They select for expertise in body language, character of voice, and rehearsal of interview questions. If they were a major factor, helicopter parents would just start enrolling their children in Theater and Acting classes.
Essays as well are victim to this. CIf it were more like the GRE's Analytical Writing section, I suppose it would be worthwhile to weight them more--but it's currently not, and essays are victim to even more cultural variables than the infamous verbal analogy section of the SAT was.
Essays can be gamed, though. I always advise people to write anecdotal essays with certain themes and they almost always turn out MUCH better. The admissions officers see the same tired essays over and over again -- and there are variants that actually stand out quite well.
I wrote mine about the Rubik's Cube -- but not in the way you'd expect.Last edited by Reincarnate; 12-29-2010, 11:13 AM.Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
This is very much true. Scores basically get stored into cutoff bins -- so a 750 isn't much different from an 800 (it can come down to one or two questions).I was talking with a stanford admissions officer a while back, and asked a question about 'brute strength' applicants, ones who simply have near perfect quantitative stats, and she told me that as long as you're within range, it doesn't matter what your numbers are, because essentially every applicant within range is of the same academic caliber. It was more holistic than anything. Don't think you can really predict if its truly holistic.
An 800 on Math IIC doesn't mean much, for instance (esp. considering that an 800 is like the 90th percentile). You can get an 800 on the IIC by missing 4 questions/skipping a few extras... or you can be that guy who didn't miss a single question and would continue to not miss questions even if you made the test twice as hard and twice as long. Both would show up as 800. But the latter candidate would likely have that skill emanating through his application elsewhere. A difference between a 700 and 800 can come down to just a small handful of questions, so admissions officers care a lot more about your academic performance and course rigor.
Very interesting article -- and I very much agree with it. A lot of people don't like to be told that their success is the result of luck or something else that ISN'T brains and hard work. When it comes from your average naysayer, it sounds like a bunch of irritable whining that gets swept under the rug and ignored. It's much easier to grow intellectually when you have a stable family with food on the table and an atmosphere of love, drive, happiness, and success.The Admissions system for undergraduate education has become a serious cluster****. Right now it encourages hoarding extracurricular "softs". Dylan Matthews of the Harvard Crimson wrote a great article about this.
So to counter this, they usually favor kids like myself who didn't come from an advantaged background (which is also why poorer black/hispanic demographics get a leg up in admissions). People don't seem to understand how much of a leg up you get by having educated parents to get advice/support/motivation from who are willing to grant you transportation/funding for EC's and other opportunities, etc. I came from a ****ty background but with juggernaut stats, killer recs, heavy EC achievement, and great essays -- hence my admissions success.
But the problem is that this gap is massive. You're going to have a ton of well-educated, high-scoring, well-rounded, high-achieving applicants who all come from good families. You aren't going to have many kids who came from nothing. So, in large part, elite schools are helping the rich get richer. This problem is further compounded by employers who won't even look at your resume unless you come from a reputable school, not to mention the fact that these graduates have already received the benefits and skills of their higher educations. Transferring also becomes very difficult. For instance, Wharton only accepted something like 30 external transfers when I was a junior, and they were all 4.0 GPA students from other top schools. It's really hard to be a state-school student who manages to transfer into an Ivy, for example.
This is why it's so important to get into a good school. You don't need a good school to be successful, no -- but it's going to be a hell of a lot harder. Earnings gaps will encompass your opportunity cost for life.Last edited by Reincarnate; 12-29-2010, 11:48 AM.Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
This thread is interesting.
I'm Canadian; I originally planned to go to the states for school and took the SAT, but changed my mind at the last minute. Was hoping to get into an Ivy league school.
Interestingly, all good Canadian schools are pretty easy to get into from high school. Most of our elite schools require fairly luke warm grades for acceptance, and there are no standardized tests we have to take (some provinces have them, but they're subject specific and contribute to your grade in that subject). Extracurriculars don't even count at many elite schools; most just look at your transcript.
Things only become problematic for admissions once you actually get into the school. Grad schools are becoming insanely competitive. All Canadian Dental schools, for example, have sub 10% acceptance rates right now even for in province students (for which the university takes preference), and Medicine and Law are becoming just as bad. D: !
Anyway, I wrote the first round of the new SAT and got a 2300. Nobody cares about higher scores 8) (Running the stats on the test, differential power of the test starts to break down around 2220 and the tests ceiling is somewhere around 2330; higher scores are statistically meaningless and can be considered equivalent, and I'm sure adcoms know this too).
We don't use GPA here in highschool, only percentages, but my average was 95% (rank 3/500. Defeated by both my gf and some bitch that got into Harvard and Yale)Last edited by Reach; 12-29-2010, 04:32 PM.
Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Yeah, SAT scores don't matter for crap once you hit 2250ish.
It's all about unweighted GPA, extracurriculars, and whether you 'click' or not.Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
I'll just list the schools I'm applying to. My stats are okay, but not phenomenal compared to other users to this site so I think it would be rather embarrassing for me to list any stats.
-University of Hawaii at Hilo
-University of Hawaii at Manoa
-University of Portland
-UCLA
-UC Berkeley
-Princeton
-MIT
-Yale
-Caltech
-Rice University
-Brown University
-University of Southern California
-StanfordAMA: http://ask.fm/benguino

Originally posted by Spenner(^)> peck peck says the heelsOriginally posted by Xx{Midnight}xXAnd god made ben, and realized he was doomed to miss. And said it was good.Originally posted by Zakvvv666awww :< crushing my dreams; was looking foward to you attempting to shoot yourself point blank and missing
Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Assuming you're from Hawaii since you have 2 schools in Hawaii up there, probably safeties.I'll just list the schools I'm applying to. My stats are okay, but not phenomenal compared to other users to this site so I think it would be rather embarrassing for me to list any stats.
-University of Hawaii at Hilo
-University of Hawaii at Manoa
-University of Portland
-UCLA
-UC Berkeley
-Princeton
-MIT
-Yale
-Caltech
-Rice University
-Brown University
-University of Southern California
-Stanford
All of your schools match mine except Caltech/MIT (assuming you're going for engineering of some sort.)
Good luck! Hopefully I can see you at Yale or Princeton or something along those lines.. :<Last edited by OneHandNow; 12-29-2010, 02:59 PM.Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Yeah, the two from Hawaii are definitely safeties! XD As for the engineering comment, I'm planning to major in computer science, which typically gets placed in the engineering field.Assuming you're from Hawaii since you have 2 schools in Hawaii up there, probably safeties.
Everything else is a match except Caltech/MIT (assuming you're going for engineering of some sort.)
Good luck! Hopefully I can see you at Yale or Princeton or something along those lines.. :<AMA: http://ask.fm/benguino

Originally posted by Spenner(^)> peck peck says the heelsOriginally posted by Xx{Midnight}xXAnd god made ben, and realized he was doomed to miss. And said it was good.Originally posted by Zakvvv666awww :< crushing my dreams; was looking foward to you attempting to shoot yourself point blank and missing
Comment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
Princeton is a match? lol.Assuming you're from Hawaii since you have 2 schools in Hawaii up there, probably safeties.
Everything else is a match except Caltech/MIT (assuming you're going for engineering of some sort.)
Good luck! Hopefully I can see you at Yale or Princeton or something along those lines.. :<
Ivies are reaches for everyone.
Arch0wl, where do you go? or did go..?
Also reuben don't be afraid to post stats, mine weren't amazing. haha.Last edited by infinity.; 12-29-2010, 02:52 PM.signatures are for nerds
nerdsComment
-
Re: High School Seniors, where are you applying?
I meant match as in, his and my schools. XD Sorry if that confused anyone. I should have worded it better.Comment
-
Comment

Comment