TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

[mellon_collie]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

um... I'll be voting, don't worry. no need to lynch me and also that logic is weird as hell

[TWGma]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

That's probably not the best way to proceed with the game. Like at all.

Says the one who wants to lynch all low-postcounters...

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

um... I'll be voting, don't worry. no need to lynch me and also that logic is weird as hell

I'm actually reeeeeeeeaally tempted to not vote and down out just how badly SunFan would throw the game trying to punish me for it or whatever.

Because using that logic at this point is straight throwing

[SubaruPoptart]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

I gotta go get ready to go to the school dance thing so I'll hopefully be back a lil before EoD. 8:00 to 10:30 EST for me so rip.

[flashflash account]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

Duskfall, FFA: either sell me on this Raeko bit or make real votes.

Because even if you convinced me she has a good chance to be scum (not likely) I doubt you can make a good case on why her over Storn, DBP, Xel or even one of you instead.

first of all, I need to give scum raeko her dues
I feel like I tunnel her every game lately but I'm probably right this time

her actual content is relatively bare, most of it is talking about the off topic stuff whoever brings it up. I don't really like that in a surface level way

her thing about reading me for flip flopping feels like a precursor to a fabricated scum read. I don't recall her ever saying I do that as scum, but I'll give her the benefit of the doubt here and see if she actually does read through my posts and draw conclusions

I don't think she will tho

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

Says the one who wants to lynch all low-postcounters...

Doing so D0 wins games

But no keep strawmanning me on the issue I'm sure I'll eventually come to your side

[mellon_collie]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

first of all, I need to give scum raeko her dues
I feel like I tunnel her every game lately but I'm probably right this time

her actual content is relatively bare, most of it is talking about the off topic stuff whoever brings it up. I don't really like that in a surface level way

her thing about reading me for flip flopping feels like a precursor to a fabricated scum read. I don't recall her ever saying I do that as scum, but I'll give her the benefit of the doubt here and see if she actually does read through my posts and draw conclusions

I don't think she will tho

dog... I read all of your posts

my statement wasn't "I am going to look through all of FFA's posts to draw a conclusion" it was "the frequency of the posts doesn't matter, the content and potential contradictions are what matter" and you bet I'm looking out for that

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

first of all, I need to give scum raeko her dues
I feel like I tunnel her every game lately but I'm probably right this time

her actual content is relatively bare, most of it is talking about the off topic stuff whoever brings it up. I don't really like that in a surface level way

her thing about reading me for flip flopping feels like a precursor to a fabricated scum read. I don't recall her ever saying I do that as scum, but I'll give her the benefit of the doubt here and see if she actually does read through my posts and draw conclusions

I don't think she will tho

Bro I could say you're 100% right in all that and she'd still be playing her town game.

Her tone, the outbust to me d0 and the fact that shes at least popping in thread tell me she's town.

Accuse me of a tone/meta read if you need to but I'm pretty sure I'm calling this one right, and it isn't like we're at a lost for other candidates

[TWGma]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

Doing so D0 wins games

But no keep strawmanning me on the issue I'm sure I'll eventually come to your side

Y'know, I'd actually like to see the math and/or science behind that.
How many games in which the D0 lynch was the lowest poster did town win. Of those lynchees, how many were actually wolves?
Blah de blah.

Regardless, the logic that I see is no different than the logic I presume you see with your argument: you get rid of people who are actively not helping town win the game.
In your case, they have no content.
In his case, they literally are not helping by not placing their votes.



So where you might see a glorious gold mine compared to a steaming heap, I just see 2 equal piles of shit.

[mellon_collie]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

Her tone, the outbust to me d0

yeah I don't think wolves are usually out here baiting arguments on purpose lol

[flashflash account]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

Y'know, I'd actually like to see the math and/or science behind that.
How many games in which the D0 lynch was the lowest poster did town win. Of those lynchees, how many were actually wolves?
Blah de blah.

Regardless, the logic that I see is no different than the logic I presume you see with your argument: you get rid of people who are actively not helping town win the game.
In your case, they have no content.
In his case, they literally are not helping by not placing their votes.



So where you might see a glorious gold mine compared to a steaming heap, I just see 2 equal piles of shit.

lynch by postcount was the most accurate of all the people making N1 guesses in the entire champs series

so lynch lowposters is >rand better than decent players making uninformed guesses

[flashflash account]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

can one of you link me to the "outburst"
I might have missed that in my catchup

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

Y'know, I'd actually like to see the math and/or science behind that.
How many games in which the D0 lynch was the lowest poster did town win. Of those lynchees, how many were actually wolves?
Blah de blah.

Regardless, the logic that I see is no different than the logic I presume you see with your argument: you get rid of people who are actively not helping town win the game.
In your case, they have no content.
In his case, they literally are not helping by not placing their votes.



So where you might see a glorious gold mine compared to a steaming heap, I just see 2 equal piles of shit.

I don't think getting rid of no content posters in a phase where you have no other leads compares to having a pretty solid lead and content to comb over but policy someone who's making posts, just hasn't voted.

Especially since I end up not voting lowest poster most d0s (like this one, actually; voted DBP because of Shadow tunnel) this just reads as you wanting to whine about how I do things but not really knowing what I actually do

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

can one of you link me to the "outburst"
I might have missed that in my catchup

I am almost certain you have referenced it yourself earlier but


It was the series of posts she did about "look I made a post on solving the game", mocking my d0 policy

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

Driving, I'll be around closer to EoD.

Really tempted to go Xel but I probably need go give it some thought