Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

[operationstrawbarry]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

gundam dude's reviews: rejected

Who saw this comming?

[gnr61]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

patashu's never had a file rejected before lMao

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

gundam dude's reviews: rejected

keepin da peace

[jimerax]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

It looks more like submitted files aren't that good rather than GD's too harsh

also looks like my chopin file was rejected after all, sadly

patashu's never had a file rejected before lMao

Didn't he have like 5 acceptances and 1 reject on DCP

[moches]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

Death Match- Why was this necessary. tora's is perfectly fine. also bad percussion layering, this feels super empty. rejected

Death Moon II- Buizel's is fine so I won't be playing this sorry. N/A

Decipher- Pretty bad. Patterns are absolutely random and never build up to anything. I like this song though (Gundam :P.) Not a good song choice. Have you seen Ducky's sticky on stepping files in this forum? That's a good place to start. rejected

Festa do Sol- Some parts of this can be really really awesome with some work, but then you have the dumpy mine usage, and misrhythms, and inconsistencies everywhere. Great song but file is missing a lot, sorry. rejected

Final Attack- Not a good file. Lots of bad stepping decisions (you stepped intense parts so easily and then stepped a single note melody as a huge jumpdump. also inaccurate/misfelt jacks.) I also think you should take a look at Ducky's sticky as it has chockloads of good advice. Good luck. rejected

Bynary Fission files: Gundam covers those better than I ever could. either way both rejected (Goddess Bound would be accepted with fixes for me though)

Lightning Doesn't Step The Percussion And Puts Loads Of Huge Jacks That Are Absolutely Torturous To Play: yeah rejected. I liked the minijacks to this though. would be a decent file if you had vary it up a little but it keeps doing the same stuff. try to find some good examples of jacking files and work your way from there.

Reincarnation- At this point in the batch I was lolling my head from side to side in hopes that that would make SM more interesting for me. File was decent however and had some pretty nice parts, one of the better ones in the batch and one of your better files. 32nd rolls are kind of lame though. rejected

Sorry I'm kind of bored and really tired. I'll play the rest later

[moches]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

patashu's never had a file rejected before lMao

I had a decent amount of files pulled/rejected from this pack

My stepmania self-confidence has since lowered a bit.

Also why the heck was jx's Chopin file rejected? I guess this pack just has pretty high standards (claimed to be RFpack level but I suspect otherwise)

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

It looks more like submitted files aren't that good rather than GD's too harsh

also looks like my chopin file was rejected after all, sadly

More or less yeah file submissions haven't been great lately. I'm not very strict when compared to say Stargroup/NPV, lol.

Also, I addressed the matter regarding Heroic Polonaise to the judges since the file never really had a final decision. Waiting for a response from everyone to see if it'll make the accept or reject list so if you wait a bit longer you'll have your answer.

[gnr61]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

the higher the standards the better imo. clearly this pack isn't having any problems getting files so i don't see why it should be accepting any "eh" files that obviously no one's going to play.

[ddrace]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

I put together a file for this.

[Patashu]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

patashu's never had a file rejected before lMao

actually I had a bunch of rejects back in vgmp2. organic and jeh jeh rocket were rejeckted, lash's theme was consumed and taken over

I had I think one in dcp? earth-like planet v2

[gnr61]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

oh. that file had BA mines

[Ghakimx]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

Sorry I'm kind of bored and really tired. I'll play the rest later

Review Final Step or something.

[jimerax]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

Also, I addressed the matter regarding Heroic Polonaise to the judges since the file never really had a final decision. Waiting for a response from everyone to see if it'll make the accept or reject list so if you wait a bit longer you'll have your answer.

well ok.

I don't mind if the pack standard is just high or something. can't find things to fix/improve in it anymore so it might be a matter of potential of the song (classicals are still cool though).

[N.T.M.]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

*feels neglected*

Dream Theater Keyboard Solo

I asked GD if the burst simplifications were alright and he said they were.

Before the "correction" I had 2 or 3 (dunnow which) accepts and everybody else said yes as long as the bursts were simplified.

I just don't see it in the OP and the new version's been submitted for a while now.

Remember, there's a read me file inside.

bursts are more simplified but your trill from measures 32-35 is very hard to hit and combo, rofl.

That's why I included this in the read me file I mentioned:

"M32B3 - Unfortunately this trill alone wasn't sufficient once the other sounds were introduced. However, since the 8ths don't occur every other note like a standard runningmen configuration, placing them as single steps would mar fluency since they'd be misconstrued with sections of the trill. Jumps were the best option by default."


Everything alright then?

bump

[Ghakimx]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

well ok.

I don't mind if the pack standard is just high or something. can't find things to fix/improve in it anymore so it might be a matter of potential of the song (classicals are still cool though).

Class X6