Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

[N.T.M.]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

o hai huzure

[alexdestructions]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

sending a file

highly doubt it'll get accepted lmao

[kommisar]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

sending a file

highly doubt it'll get accepted lmao

then it won't get accepted


derp.



realized re-barf is banned here so i might as well post his judgings.




11Eleven - dj sharpnel/10. This was actually kinda fun as a pad file, except for the 32nds. But with this being not a pad pack, no accep

A Parenthesis In Eternity - repetitive as holy hell

Bad Maniacs - Looks really fun. What's with the long freezes though? I don't see what they go to. accep

Blood for Justice - feels like it might be understepped at some parts. replay value is iffy. I'm not sure about this

Chaos Energy - pad file. Really good for a pad file. But once again this pack isn't for pad files. I'd definitely reccommend you for any currently open pad pack though. I think this comment will apply for all of your submissions if they're all like this

Death Moon - a bit more geared towards keyboard players, but we don't really need a death moon file. There are so many of them out there =/

Don't Be Afraid Myself - see chaos energy

Dual Control - see chaos energy

Fuchnikan Candy - see chaos energy

God Knows - same thing

Love Magic - I think the KBC3 simfile for this is funner to play actually.

Mononokebutou - song doesn't offer too much for a good simfile. doesn't seem interesting enough to keep the general population's interest

neoMAX - see chaos energy

Programmed World - see chaos energy

Siin - meh sharpnel

Urapara Core - I think this is the only keyboard file you've actually submitted. And I say this probably only because its faster and has more jumps than all your other files. but meh sharpnel. Not really what we're looking for

Volcano - repetitive song and steps. not very interesting

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

for a sec I thought those were your reviews and I was about to say "nice job rebirf"

(Jimerax) Binary Rendezvous
Jacks are a bit tough to hit but add a nice scoring factor. Very fun file. Accepted

(BeatOfIke) Stars Biscuit
Oh god Kotoko. Decently structured and layered however generic and not quite what this pack is looking for. Rejected

(Ninzaburo) Babylon V2
Generic and isn't pack worthy. Rejected

(Ninzaburo) Papyrus
Good song but file wasn't as good as I hoped. Rejected

(Don) Pop
Strongly reminds me of Stargroup's piano demo files, rofl. Straightforward and sweet. Lightly Accepted

(Don) Tune in Again
The better of your two submissions. Very cool file. Only thing I can mention is that one handed 32nd trill or whatever is awkward/hard to hit and it drags on a bit. Accepted

(OperationStrawbarry) Knife
Generic, repetitive, and not what this pack is looking for. Rejected

(Paradox) Limit Grove 02
Old school-esque. Generic, repetitive, and not what this pack is looking for. Rejected

(Paradox) Love Comes
Old school-esque. Generic, repetitive, and not what this pack is looking for. Rejected

(Paradox) Nose Breath 98
Old school-esque. Generic, repetitive, and not what this pack is looking for. Rejected

(Paradox) Odysee in 3D
Old school-esque. Generic, repetitive, and not what this pack is looking for. Rejected

(Paradox) Roking Sun
Old school-esque. Generic, repetitive, and not what this pack is looking for. Rejected

(Paradox) Tokyo Rush
Old school-esque. Freeze abuse. Generic, repetitive, and not what this pack is looking for. Rejected

(Moches) Papyrus
Drags on but was pretty cool and enjoyable. Accepted

(Ferrari) A Simple Life V2
Better than the first version. Even with fixes, still rather repetitive and I don't see much that this file offers. Rejected

==========================================================================

(Rebirth vs. Dew) Slasher Blue
Ken Nakagawa. Well structured and enjoyable. Immediately noticed Dew's signature 24th/32nd burst patterns (aka Necrofantasia). Only complaints is that it drags on a bit and hands seem kinda random at times (complex layering). Accepted

(Rebirth) Apocalypse ~dirge of swans~
Jumpstream with the jumps following vocals kinda irked me but I guess it's better than having bass jumps or layering both at once. Well structured but I'm questioning the replay value of this file. Maybe

(Rebirth) Magical Voices Shower
File didn't really offer much other than vocal holds. Rejected

(MetzgerSM) A Parenthesis in Eternity
Repetitive and generic as ****. Quit out. Rejected

(Dimentio) Love Magic
Well structured and somewhat enjoyable. I haven't played the KBC3 file but this looks like a conversion of the BCMP4 file, rofl. Don't really know if this is pack material though. Maybe

(Huzure) 11Eleven
Decent for a pad file. As a keyboard file, absolutely not. Also Sharpnel. Rejected

(Huzure) God Knows (Follow You Mix)
Decent for a pad file. As a keyboard file, absolutely not. Also Sharpnel. Rejected

(Huzure) Programmed World
Good pad file but this is a keyboard only pack, sorry. Rejected

(Huzure) Siin
Decent for a pad file. As a keyboard file, absolutely not. Also Sharpnel. Rejected

(Huzure) Urapara Core
Decent for a hard pad file. As a keyboard file, absolutely not. Also Sharpnel. Rejected

(Huzure) Chaos Energy
Good pad file but this is a keyboard only pack, sorry. Rejected

(Huzure) Fuchinkan Candy
Good pad file but this is a keyboard only pack, sorry. Rejected

(Huzure) NeoMAX
Good pad file but this is a keyboard only pack, sorry. Rejected

(Huzure) Don't Be Afraid Myself
Good pad file but this is a keyboard only pack, sorry. Rejected

(Huzure) Death Moon
for the love of god please stop ****ing stepping this song. I'm not even going to play it based on your other submissions and this song has been stepped 193471928361237189436718937198379812379812739812739813 times and all versions of this song suck. Auto-Reject.

(Huzure) Dual Control
Good pad file but this is a keyboard only pack, sorry. Rejected

(Kommisar vs. ZIM) Bad Maniacs
Ugh your song choice. Cool xmodlive gimmicks and mine theory. Lightly Accepted

(trumaestro) Blood for Justice V2
Congrats, you're the newest member of the V2 crew. lmao you basically just replaced most of the stream from V1 with mines. I didn't really like it TBH. File drags on a bit after the verse repeats. I probably won't accept this here, but I might accept this for LCP if you send it there too. Rejected.

(Ninzaburo) Volcano
Generic jumpstream to a generic song. Once again, decent understanding of file structure and layering but not quite packworthy. Rejected

(Ninzaburo) Mononokebutou
The better of your 2 submissions this batch. I thought the file ended at Measure 68 so at least put a couple mines to signify that the file hasn't ended yet. Once again, decent understanding of file structure and layering but not quite packworthy. Rejected

[alexdestructions]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

then it won't get accepted

well it probably could if it wasn't so overstepped by bynary lol

[-paexaea-]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

gd, you forgot my file in the accepted files

also if someone steps demetori, i'll love you forever since dew was a ****** a year ago and said it was too good to be stepped

[kommisar]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

your file needs sync work. fix dat and we'll accep




HOW IS BAD MANIACS A BAD SONG

[kommisar]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

(Rebirth vs. Dew) Slasher Blue auto-accep because of nostalgia

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

gd, you forgot my file in the accepted files

also if someone steps demetori, i'll love you forever since dew was a ****** a year ago and said it was too good to be stepped

yeah, majority agreed that the file needs resyncing before we can list it as accepted

maybe if I was still in my hot sexy touhou metal phase, I'd've stepped some tracks from them. I'll dig through their albums and see if I can find anything I'd really want to step that's not Necrofantasia because everyone has stepped that song

[Ghakimx]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

Step Chinese Tea or something.

[jimerax]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

so were files that aren't on the accepted list basically rejected?

[gnr61]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

still don't see visitor on there i sent it to kommi a while ago >__>

is there anything that can be done to salvage battaglia or is it just too dumpy lol i can only think of a handful of changes i want to make

[kommisar]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

can you send both to the e-mail


my sm 3.9 crapped

[jimerax]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

why don't you just send them to the pack e-mail?

[gnr61]

Re: Xoon 5: The Transition Submissions Open

ah i'll send visitor but i guess i'll just hold on to battaglia then for reworking over break. i'd also be free to judge during that time but you guys seem to have that down pretty efficiently which is sweet 8) (does kil know about this pack btw lol)