Stepmania Simfile Tourney

[kommisar[os]]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

compilation of the best files ye.


also looking for a 3rd judge to fill in for puppet

[Patashu]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

ooh ooh ooh

I know someone who can judge X)

[Patashu]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

btw do you do any adjustments or is it just average of all three judge's scores for each file. because for instance if one of the judges consistently rates over a larger range than the others he or she gets undue weight in how each file is ranked. imagine if two judges scored mostly between 3 and 4 /5 and the other one between 0 and 5 /5 for instance

[stargroup]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

I've never taken ap stat so I have no idea how the standard deviation and all that sh*t works

oh well

notes coming

[stargroup]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

balloon park

very nice, one of your better files. overall, everything was pretty much ok. pattern choice is getting much better, and heading toward the right direction. keep experimenting with them. very nice green note usage.
only freeze I had a real problem with was the one at the end of measure 16 that goes into 17
nothing to say really, very solid file

switchblade

first of all, watch out for technical errors. there's one in measure 2 lmfao
this is a simple file, so my comments will be pretty picky. first, make sure your steps are consistent. your 8th jack usage wasn't, for example. [13]2[12] and [23]2[13] patterns are fine, but then you did stuff like [23]4[13]. if you playtested them enough you'll realize they feel completely different. not what you want.
the next part of the song, where you do the alternating jump thing with the freezes, it's be a lot better if the freezes were "pitch relevant"
there's also the issue that the steps feel somewhat generic but considering the song I'll let that pass, not really any other way to do it


you're welcome

[Patashu]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

don't think you'd need to worry about standard deviation, just something like
1. move the judge's lowest score to 0
2. move the judge's highest score to 5
3. scale every other score so that it's at the same percentage level on the new 0-5 range as it was on the old range of min score-max score

you could look at what they did for the last competition over at r21freak, I remember they used some statistical thing to make all judges have equal weighting which is why I thought to bring it up at all

[kommisar[os]]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

i just average all the judges scores really.


also who can judj

[Frozen Beat]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

Go go go Pat.

[moches]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

balloon park

very nice, one of your better files. overall, everything was pretty much ok. pattern choice is getting much better, and heading toward the right direction. keep experimenting with them. very nice green note usage.
only freeze I had a real problem with was the one at the end of measure 16 that goes into 17
nothing to say really, very solid file

you're welcome

so I don't have to say thank you? :P

and what's the order of the rankings? Puppet-Stargroup-Psycho, or Stargroup-Puppet-Psycho, or...yeah, what?

[kommisar[os]]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

psycho-dimentio-stargroup

[moches]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

only Dimentio is you or Kil so...:/

[kommisar[os]]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

i cant even access the dimentio email anymore so ye-



could be anyone at this point

[lurkerasdf]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

as far as you know dimentio could be moches
also i got the highest score from one guy and second lowest from another lmfao
hey dragoonhead let's both step dj sharpnel

[Kraezymann]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

Forgive me for being a stepmania nub but I'm not sure what the error is in measure 2 -_-

As well, when you mention the alternating jumps with freezes, pitch relevency would have meant moving the freezes to go up or down with the sounds in the song, right? I'm assuming this was toward the beginning of the song because now that you mention it, I noticed the other sounds that the freezes could/should have gone to

[dragoonhead]

Re: Stepmania Simfile Tourney

hey dragoonhead let's both step dj sharpnel

No sorry i've something better in mind