FFR Community Pack

[EnR]

Re: FFR Community Pack

moches, my PM box was full, resend that PM.

[gnr61]

Re: FFR Community Pack

consider FAXX submitted, i've already spoken with npv about it.

[ferrari93]

Re: FFR Community Pack

Engine Room- 3.5/5 Actually a hell of a lot better than I thought it would be. The jacky parts weren’t pitch relevant, and the main melody could have accented with freezes, but I’ll give you a lot of credit because it was fun and the layering was great.

I did freezes at first, but freezes r gay. the jumps r more fun and do u mean the jacks at the middle (?)..the ones with just single notes and with a 24th note added in to layer in the snares? i really want a file in this cuz my files are decent lol.

[operationstrawbarry]

Re: FFR Community Pack

Comments that NFC made on Disconnected hardkore and Trip machine Pheonix. I want to fix this, but the comments are kind of vague. My response but no one got back to me.

Didn't know what you were talking about the weird placed 16th notes. But I found what you were talking about and I fixed it. But I dont know what jacks you mean, unless you talking about the last 16th note of the song. Will need more elaboration.

Trip Machine Pheonix doesn't have guitars from what I can hear, so I dont know where you are talking about. Have to give it to me by measure. Or are you thinking about a different song.

Can someone get back to me on this? Is this what npv and kommi both think also? didn't see their review.

At least one of my files got into the pack... well semi I guess since its not totally mine. But a VS is better than nothing LOL. Thx Kommi.

Dont forget to put my Hell Hath No Fury by Klute That I sent you through AIM into que circulation npv... not sure why its not there, but I do want to submit it.

Edit: One favor. Id perfer you dont use wappanese or jappanese anime on the Nows the Fing Time as graphix unless its ecchi or non nude sexy hentai. LOL

[leadafro]

Re: FFR Community Pack

FIGHT_X- 4.25/5 This was fun and well layered. I didn’t like the mine gimmick with the quads and the single notes following it because it pretty much cheats the player and I actually failed on them once, lmao. Also, at the halfway point, it got increasingly obvious that the second part of the song would be cut, paste, and some variation of mirroring. Still very fun, just please space the mines further from the quads, please. Or, make an Edit with the original gimmick and a Heavy with the mines more easily placed.

Fine I can space them a bit I geuss...But they are pretty easy to dodge.

Kommisar play the solo file for it.

[SulferDragon]

Re: FFR Community Pack

Hmmm... I have one other file that I could send to this, but it still needs a bit of work, more than I would be willing to do. The sync is still kind of off in some spots and the steps might need a little work here and there, but that's about it, the entire thing is already stepped. The song is The Turning by Symphony X; it's prog metal. Does anybody want to take it and finish it for me because I'd hate to just leave it after all the freaking time I spent on it? You would definitely getting the better end of the deal, unless you restepped the whole thing, har har! (I'm asking for a collab in case you didn't notice... no, I'm begging for a collab)

btw, about Final Battle. I know I left the artist as Unknown, but that's because I honestly don't know who did it. Brawl has like 8950503 composers and it doesn't say who did it in the credits, or anywhere else I've looked. If someone knows and can change it, go ahead.

[moches]

Re: FFR Community Pack

Oh, big news.

The pack website is up!

http://ffrcommunitypack.googlepages.com/home

[operationstrawbarry]

Re: FFR Community Pack

On m49 the very first note, should be a triplet. Just add a < (Left note) on that part in the the Another planet file that I sent in from

[moches]

Re: FFR Community Pack

I typed up a long-ass review for Windsprints.

Windsprints: 3.5/5 What can I say, the file was…..interesting, to be understating. I had to play Heavy twice to decide a good rating for it. Heavy was fun, and well layered, and pitch relevancy was pretty great, other than some minor stuff here and there (jacks at the beginning?). Especially the 12th consecutive jumps, I had to mash that part. The ending could have been more layered to catch more sounds at once, also, like that 12th ascending scale. Maybe layering freezes in? It’s good for what the song has, but it can be even better.

Kommi and npv should probably post notes soon. I'll be out all day tomorrow, so I'm doing as much as I can right now. Cramming for CST, reading Bag of Bones (126 pages through), and playing SM.

[dore]

Re: FFR Community Pack

I know what you mean. The parts I underlayered were the parts that turned out to be a complete cluster**** when I layered it properly. I want to write a fully layered solo chart but haven't gotten around to it yet. For singles it really felt awkward (even more so than those jump runs at the beginning).

(the jacks at the beginning were to that dinging percussion sound that rolls through that whole section)

[omgitznpv]

Re: FFR Community Pack

Time to start my endless judging.

Finally have time, haha. Looking forward to some of the files.


*EDIT* Will edit as I keep judging.

The Five - sc979

2.5/5

Quite a few errors. The beginning is pretty lame. Jump usage throughout the entire file is annoying and sometimes strange. Not really fun to play. Inconsistency. The stream halfway in the file or whatever is awkward. The ending hold can be much shorter or something.




Trip Machine Phoenix - OperationStrawbarry

2/5

Beginning holds are strange. The file is offsync at quite a few parts, and it winds up going offbeat. You've missed a lot of stuff in this thing. Jumps/hands can be odd at times to me. A couple jacks aren't too fun for me.




Disconnected Hardkore - OperationStrawbarry

2/5

Some of the file is offsync. Some parts are understepped (middle). Missed a lot of stuff. The quads in the middle make no sense. Hand choice can be better I think. Jack usage is inconsistent/annoying.




Blood For Justice - trumaestro

4/5 (accepted anyways)

Good job fixing it up. There are still some minor problems, which I can fix up myself now if you want me to. The first 24th staircase and where ever that repeats- it's still incorrect and even if you meant it to be 24ths anyways, a better way to step it exists. The 32nds in the part with the synth slides are to the slides, right? If so, they could be synced/done better. A couple of jumps are strange to me, such as where you have some red? arrow and a jump on a 32nd and then a single on a 64th or something. The jump is strange to me. Also, during the solo part, the 64ths or whatever can be emphasized better to the harmonics (iirc that's what they were but I don't remember well) such as with a mini-freeze.




Now's The ****ing Time - OperationStrawbarry vs. Kommisar

4.5/5

Wooooooooow this was fun. Some of the mini-freezes felt unnecessary to me and could be done differently. It eventually got a bit repetitive, but it's okay. The very last arrow I think could carry more emphasis to the last sound or whatever.



Desperate Struggle - RandomDragoon

3.5/5

This was quite fun for me. You opened the file in an annoying way- figure out a better way to do it, I guess. There were a few missed sounds, I think, that could have been layered in as occasional jumps. The solo part could have been emphasized more, IMO. The ending holds are WAY TOO LONG.




Final Battle - SulferDragon

4/5

Gap seemed to be a few ms early. The colored arrows in the beginning shouldn't be different arrows, IMO. A couple of the holds were strange for me, but whatever. Fun file.




I <3 Voltage (v2) - EnR vs. Moches

4/5

PR in the beginning is like ?____________? Jacks are annoying. Otherwise :ver 8):




Nebula - Xiaounlimited

3.5/5

I found this really fun. Missed a lot of 32nds, though. The beginning and some other parts of the file are kind of awkward. Hold usage confuses me a bit.




Fight X - leadafro

4/5

I find this really really fun. The mines after the quads can be spaced out a bit more. You possibly could emphasize the synth or whatever it is during the jumpstream a bit more with mini-freezes but I dunno.




Engine Room - ferrari93

4/5

wowowowowowowowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww cool file. My only complaints are that the PR on some of the 12th jacks with a 24th is incorrect. I also think you missed a hand and made it a jump instead, but I'm too lazy to check that out and see if you actually did.




Windspirits - dore

3.5/5

Jacks in the beginning are too much. If you fix that then you don't need the standard chart, I'd guess.




Another Planet - OperationStrawbarry

2.5/5

Get rid of the subtitle x(
The quads and hands were REALLY REALLY REALLY dumb to me and made the file really annoying. The opening jacks also annoyed me a bit, but it's probably because my left hand is retarded. You missed a lot of stuff. Offsync at parts.



wow i accepted 5 new files either people can step now or i'm just being really lenient




















WOOOOOOW GNR YOUR FILE IS AMAZING except i bet the other judges would probably reject it for being too hard 8)

just get rid of da million jumpjacks cuz those are kinda TOO hard and uncessary
in da beginnin were da melody comes in maybe ya should emphasize dem or somethin i dunno
those beat 32nds im assuming were odd so get them on beat ya douche even if it seems slightly wrong but thats better than having them as 32nds
da hands were too much in the beginnin n **** maybe shave off a bit
da 16ths at the very end made no sense

brb playing this again for cools 8)

[EnR]

Re: FFR Community Pack

I might step something else, I'm sorta just want to step stuff for ffr, since I don't like using holds and sm files use holds/

[moches]

Re: FFR Community Pack

wow i accepted 5 new files either people can step now or i'm just being really lenient

probably the latter; the last time I ever had to give a 2 to a file was like three weeks ago.

keep up the good work guys!

p.s. npv, I'll fix the pitch relevancy at the beginning. Give me some time plz.

[ferrari93]

Re: FFR Community Pack

HI GUYS!!! great to know u <3 my file. btw, i made a fix; i submit sometime nxt week...i fixed the jacks and mostly everything. its still easily AAA'able lol but oh well.

[moches]

Re: FFR Community Pack

HI GUYS!!! great to know u <3 my file. btw, i made a fix; i submit sometime nxt week...i fixed the jacks and mostly everything. its still easily AAA'able lol but oh well.

Awesome, you've got a lot of potential.