The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

[XOX]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

omg, don't take DS so serious, he is just helping you to be a better simfile maker!
thanks for the critics dudes!

[Professor Raine]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

Nice to know how the pack is gonna turn out.


Now can someone upload it to another site? www.fliefront.com won't let me download. Someone out there to help me?

[Wyde]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

Well, feck. I get the chance to download it, and FileFront decides to hate me for no reason, and not let me. Guess I'll have to try downloading it later...

And also, Raine: lol fliefront.

[Professor Raine]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

>_< I just wanna kill that site. megaupload pwns any day.

[kommisar[os]]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

megagayload takes downloads at an amazing 24kb/s which is awesome.

ps thanks for all the reviews guys

[ThanhSakiSuki]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

I prefer harsh criticism. Its a great way to help the simfile artist get better.

[XOX]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

true

[Litodude]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

From what I've read so far, this pack doesn't seem quite that good. I'll dl it later and critique it myself.

DS is probably 99.999% right with his calls though.

[windsurfer-sp]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

Downloading, thanks for the heads up.

[MrRubix]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

Actually constructive criticism, in my opinion, is best done with evidence for improvement. It's fine to slip in generalized opinions, but saying "I hated this file" is not really constructive criticism -- it's not going to help the stepfile maker if you just say you didn't like it. It's better to explain what you didn't like about the file, as you've done for the most part -- but try to avoid sweeping comments.

[kommisar[os]]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

i've debated that before, but not everyone feels like posting criticism. Some just want to give their opinion.

[MrRubix]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

Which is fine, but I want to point out that the best way to improve something is to give alternate suggestions and criticisms of specific aspects as opposed to just saying "I didn't like it"

[kommisar[os]]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

true. better than saying YA FILEZ SUCK ROFL **** YA DAD etc.

[ClAsSiC_RoCkEr]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

lol at seraph...

Having to say "holy **** your files are ****ty" isn't exactly the best way to push a stepfile artist to get better, so I hope you get better at that. My files were in the very least decent IMO and I appreciate your comments, but little tidbits of your comments like "ass" or "****ty" doesn't do you justice in me having to trust myself with your criticism (I don't like your files either rofl..) I don't need to be an OMGAwesome stepfile author to know that much.

So I'll stick to my own style of sensible file-making for the not-so-elite and worry less about the type of senseless bull**** that you attempt to type on your keyboard thinking "oh my, let's bash on this simfile artist because I made then he did roflmao".

[L_eMo_N]

Re: The SMGroove Community Revival Pack is released! (page 1 for link)

Lol... exactly my point... what your talking about... constructive criticism??? wtf is that... this file is "****ty", anybody could say that about a simfile... an elementary school kid could say that... but coming from DS?!?!?! yeah... bit childish i think... The authors of these simfiles did work hard on them, and they got accepted into this pack, give them credit, and as Mr. Rubix said... point out the flaws, rather than to bash like you did... ^_^