Keyboard Collaboration III

[MrGiggles]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

Goddamn, this pack reminded me how much I still suck at SM =*(

I can't handle all those jumps. It was the first thing I noticed with a bunch of files. "Oh holy **** what is this oh my god I suck" is pretty much what went through my mind.

I dunno about anyone else, but that's just my opinion.

[braintrust]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

Uh, no. I remember dballin making that point before. It just seems to me that some of these other goons are just going with the trendwagon and claiming that the files are too generic, even though that's the type of stuff they've been playing.

Some of us actually care. I probably close out of 6/10 of the new files I open (unless I'm on SMO, which nowadays is rare). 5 out of those 6 times is because 30 measures in I realize that it's either been then same measure repeated over and over again, or because it's just simply not interesting. The other 1 of those 6 is because I suck and I fail.

Now, I don't always dislike "generic" files. I would consider Ageha failrly generic, yet I think it's fun. But my favorite files are like Girl Boy Song, Ami Furi, and Murmur Twins (for the parts when it follows the piano). I like songs that aren't repetitive, cause if the song isn't, then the sim shouldn't be either.

[Zanthro]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

What it comes down to is, what files are we going to actually go back and play in the future.Every pack has a few replayable files and the truth is most of all packs that come out 3/4 of the songs are just waste and canditates for songs that will be replayed.So what really matters and what what we should be talking about is , what files are we going to go back and play 3 or 4 months from now??for Me I can think of about 4.What are the files in this pack that have replay value to you??

[ddrdanc3r55]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

Downloading. I'd like to help more with the next one.

[dballin4]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

What are the files in this pack that have replay value to you??

Maybe about 1 or two of them. =( Rai's 2 files I played were good. Everything else I've played is meh.

[medik]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

im pretty much done with the sm community, no real fun here

if someone wants to take over otfd, i can give them the layout but they need their own host

[HST]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

Okay, just downloaded it.

I really like these so far:
I need to play other artists besides the swede people's...
- Tristram Rock
- The Least 333 sec.
- Jurs OP

To be honest I hate all of my stuff. There is too much of a time difference between the creation of the simfiles and as such, my way of making the files changed over time. Ernst was crap; Zenius and Be Quiet were decent (also most recent). I really should have saved C'mon! Swing All-stars for this pack.

The pack is not bad, it's something to pass the time with. I hope for many of the authors out there that they take this as a springboard towards ap's pack (if they plan to do something for it) in terms of learning from any comments made about it rather than argue opinions about the simfiles that will probably never change.

[Rebirth0]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

I'll take over OTFD rofl, I've been wanting a website for 1289423496129375 minutes.

[Hr2]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

I never finished fixing sin, it'll be coming out on my own pack

this pack will only have one file

it will be sin and called sinful megapack

[Z3ratul]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

Brace yourself, R^n.

Cute.

I've just finished playing every file in the pack. All and all, I'd say it turned out well.

Top 3:

We Met Dat Night- I love Vospi's files.

Istanbul Cafe- This file is gold.

TLS333S- There's some stuff in the first third of the file that I would've thought Lurk would do differently... meh. Still, incredible file- what I've come to expect from him.

Most of the rest weren't bad. Some were boring, and some were crap, but on the whole (even most of the 'generic' files) I found it to be fun. Again, good job guys. I'm happy with it

[Bursurk_Lurk]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

have a enjoy

btw when can we release our simfiles at bms etc

[Bursurk_Lurk]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

who cares

ill do it anyway

[Rewind690]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

HST, ur Be Quiet is EXTREMELY fun, for me atleast lol.

[HST]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

Haha that's weird, BlueMystic, you, and others have said that Be Quiet was their favorite. I guess you want stuff with rhythms that constantly change throughout the song. I'll take note of this then since I find Be Quiet to be fun as well.

Well, I like RaiRai's stuff in this one. Still haven't found time to play yet...finals are kicking in as of late.

[BlueMystik]

Re: Keyboard Collaboration III

I guess you want stuff with rhythms that constantly change throughout the song.

Excactly. big stream files filled with jumps on other notes in the music suck, and are not creative at all, or fun or good for that matter. It doesn't have to have crazy 24th and 64th and 128th notes or whatever the **** AP's new sims use. 16th patterns just need to vary more. Jumps on every note possible are not neccessary unless you want maybe a hard file, which every file does not need to be like that.