ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

[kommisar]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

choof you don't like apocynthion because it's hard and your blubbering vagina fingers can't keep up


get good at the game


******

[Mollocephalus]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

lol

[Choofers]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

choof you don't like apocynthion because it's hard and your blubbering vagina fingers can't keep up


get good at the game


******

oh okay man
what's your score on it

[kommisar]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

A


.


.

[AlexDest]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

choof you don't like apocynthion because it's hard and your blubbering vagina fingers can't keep up


get good at the game


******

the patterns blow major ass

[FissionMailed1]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

[04im]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

Dunkin' Donuts

[Coolboyrulez0]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

[04im]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

oops im oom sry guys.. ...

[ScylaX]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

Reviewing the second half of the pack and files you told me I forgot bros
Still I really want to make it clear that I don't plan on reviewing every single chart because HEH that pack is titanic!!!

My So-Called Life (mi40) Ok so the charting of the intro/outro is really good and that mine work has the benefit to be SIMPLE and EFFICIENT at the same time. Your drum layering is flawless, the only "bad" notice I have is how you chose to layer that weird synth in the middle instead of focusing on the bass. It could have been a nice touch to layer the bass in the middle portion with some subtle freezes but it's still a gr8t file.

Light House (Valor) I found the second half to be funnier than the first one. If I had to make a file over this song I'm sure it would be 80% different from what you did ; the simplicity of your approach seemed a bit weak to me at first, but I enjoyed tapping these notes toward the end so......

Paradise Lost (Nick Skyline) Hey these final freezes didn't needed to be that long I think hahaha anyway very good file for scoring will replay for sure. The layering is great, the only part that confused me was the dramatic come-back in the middle with these strange trills but it was still very enjoyable.

Plasmatextor (Stargroup) Frustrating jacks overall typical stargroup file I guess?????

Polssia (Leone510) WERE ALL THESE JUMPS AND TRIPS REALLY NEEDED ? Anyway the file is quite fun and I loved the bursts but I think even though the song is intense, abusing of doubles/trips was really drowning your chart into chaos.

Red Nikita (Charu) osamu kubota <33 There are small portions in this that are really intense despite the song being quite... elegant and smooth??? There are patterns that didn't reflected that smoothness and felt hard and brutal comparatively to what the song conveyed. I think you should have tried to put more freezes. Adopting a more tactical layering would have been nice too.

Requiem for a Team (spitfire) Very good and fun. Your style mixes very well with that kind of music. I'll replay it for sure.

Resurrected Replayer (Kommi) Clearly not your best file but still cool nonetheless. What's cool with you is that even your bad files are nice to play.

Rip Roar Power (MrTea) Nice for scoring ; putting that aside I didn't really like it. this is like the little brother of Cyberstorm : it shares the same identity but I just find Cyberstorm cooler and funnier to play. I felt there was a problem with how you grasped the intensity of the music. Can't say how though.
I really liked Szycag though

Sin (cetaka) Yeah well it's been a long time now since the first time I played this file and my opinion didn't change : still not as good as puppet's (also it better be the last Sin file before a long moment.)

snew sturm (ilikexd) That long 48th stream was a very very good idea to express the coldness and all that. I don't really like the music (the instrument are as cheesy as they can get) but you managed to pull out a good file from that.

Space is Key (SPACE) PAINFULLLL file. overall the file is nice and solid but.....

SpeedDial (IcyWorld) I like how your style allies simplicity and pure jolts of fun. Legit difficulty and perfect layering, the solos are kickass
10/10 file
(icy as good as ever)

St. Alphonzo (Scintill) You have the capacity to spawn super great files with songs I would have considered to be UNSTEPPABLE otherwise. Genius job.

Swing Set (Yesssss) I guess it's okay..... don't think I'll replay it or anything but I didn't hated it... just not my kind of thing.

Synaptic Plasticity (Fission) Good for a mathcore file. I'm not a fan of that sort of music but you managed to make it likeable.

The bridgeport run (Torrent) I love your way to layer IDM like that.

Transparent World (midnight) played oni ; the layering was kinda bad to me ; the streams were okay, that what made the file fun to me...
And the final part was HAAAARRD. Everything else could be fine but... I don't know if you fixed that in your easier difficulties, however making a 16th running man + jumps on 8th notes was ABSOLUTELY NOT NECESSARY and very unpleasant to tap at that. If you wanted to emphasize the brutality of the snare drums then laying trips would have done the thing. I can't see the use of 16th note for that part. Plus it appears at the end of the file so your arms are meant to be tired at the moment, and you have that jolt of difficulty that suddenly makes all the whole thing WAY HARDER.
(I can't imagine how difficult it must be on edit)

tranzport (valor) Ok so the jumpstream at the end wasn't necessary I think, you could have ended the file with simple 8th jumps and trips to emphasize the beat. That aside, the file is very VERY good, you had a lots of great ideas and executed them very well (the rolls in the first part that followed the pitch bending of the looong saw + the freeze monopoly in the middle). Of course it's not as innovative as the version we all played (aperson's file is crazy on that point) but at the same time it felt like you corrected all of the STRANGENESS that were present in ap's file and that annoyed me.
I wondered how one could step it without plagiarizing aperson's file while being as good as ap's and you succeeded to pull out a very enjoyable file. A++ will play again

tzuicha-cha (skorpionx9) Definitely a fun file. I'll maybe replay it someday. I found your layering to be very violent sometimes but I guess it was necessary somehow.

Unconnected (Nick Skyline) The problem I had when I tried to step that song is that the breaks may sound very fun and cool to step, but they reveal to be... quite the opposite in fact. Still a good attempt, I think that's one of the worse file I played from you and I think the song is to blame. (also it doesn't mean the file's bad!!!!! just that it's clearly not as great as the other files you made for that pack peace)

V^3 (mi40) Perfect execution of the chaos that crawls in this song. And by that I mean that's the kind of file with a legit difficulty that is still pleasant to play putting aside the fact it kills your arms.

ZEN (Mr Bob) Simple but powerful. I love your files man, I hope you'll make more in the future.

== KARMA-field== (Stargroup & Don) The final part was my favourite, the rest of the file is very fun too. It lives up to the overall quality of the pack. Good job.

also top 7 of my favorites files !!
1. Laveran no Shokutaku
2. Mirage Garden
3. Cyberstorm
4. Nth Degree
5. tranzport
6. Speed Dial
7. Apocynthion Drive

honourable mention : MarioStep ; YoshL's files (all of them!!)

[xVaLoRx]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

yay I made someone's top 5

[Charu]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

If you think oni is too difficult for Red Nikita, my original intention was the Heavy. But I deemed it way too easy for the pack so that's why oni exists in the first place, doho.

Yeah, I didn't put any freezes either because I didn't want to ruin the flow. (And I can't tell what's a good freeze pattern to use.)

[j-rodd123]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

haven't played through a lot of the pack, but some files i think are really fun so far and will keep replaying:
polssia, bridgeport run, reefer man, fallen world, i like trains, narcolepsy, ultraviolent junglist, dishevel, asdf, blue rose, mirage garden

files i really did not like and won't be playing again:
sane to more, aegis, lockene, empty skydiving, fashion queen.

also the hardest files are actually fun (waltz of big dogs especially) and ge4ce was fun for what it was even though i can't pass it.

also the files that were in this pack that had a chart in ffr, it seems like the chart on ffr was 100 times better in both instances (toki and demon beast appearance) haha. captain murasa was equally as fun on ffr and sm but it's a gd file so expected.

anyways, overall super fun pack awesome stuff!

[Choofers]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

A


.


.

nice

[ScylaX]

Re: ODIPack3 Simfile Reviews

If you think oni is too difficult for Red Nikita, my original intention was the Heavy. But I deemed it way too easy for the pack so that's why oni exists in the first place, doho.

Yeah, I didn't put any freezes either because I didn't want to ruin the flow. (And I can't tell what's a good freeze pattern to use.)

Got it! I'll try heavy in a near future.
However, why do you think freezes may ruin the flow in that one ? When I talked about them I actually thought about minifreezes, it's a smooth way to emphasize the importance of a voice without having to add another note (which is a choice that can significantly overload the whole chart).
Anyway it's all up to you and I guess having that kind of taste is what preserves the diversity of styles (since it's really not related to the quality of your chart) but I just wanted to point that out.