What Constitutes a "Good Chart"?

[stargroup100]

Re: What Constitutes a "Good Chart"?

Quality of responses to this question has improved dramatically over the years. Good job everyone

[riktoi]

Re: What Constitutes a "Good Chart"?

a good chart is one that has my favorite artists

[ositzxz369]

Re: What Constitutes a "Good Chart"?

The definition of a good chart? Where you start like—you like, you start with like a nice roll... like—(snare rush fades in). And then you go—you get like sorta crazy with your patterns—you're like—(cymbal crashes appear, breaks follow). Right? And then you like step something like... scary? Maybe like, 'Ooh yeah, a freaked out child in the woods.' And then you do that again. You go like—(snare rush fades in again, more breaks follow). And that's pretty much it.

[M0nkeyz]

Re: What Constitutes a "Good Chart"?

1.) A good chart should in some way represent the music, I think both dump charters and technical charters generally try to follow the intensity of the music.
2.) From my experience people react more positively to charts/songs that have interesting rhythms and pattern variety.
3.) Good is subjective, you may really like a chart someone else dislikes.
4.) Submit to packs/FFR/osu!mania, try to get as much feedback as possible. This is how I grew as a charter and this is how I'm still growing. Feedback is everything.

[XelNya]

Re: What Constitutes a "Good Chart"?

1.) A good chart should in some way represent the music, I think both dump charters and technical charters generally try to follow the intensity of the music.
2.) From my experience people react more positively to charts/songs that have interesting rhythms and pattern variety.
3.) Good is subjective, you may really like a chart someone else dislikes.
4.) Submit to packs/FFR/osu!mania, try to get as much feedback as possible. This is how I grew as a charter and this is how I'm still growing. Feedback is everything.

never osumania

not even fucking once

[Zyxel]

Re: What Constitutes a "Good Chart"?

The definition of a good chart? Where you start like—you like, you start with like a nice roll... like—(snare rush fades in). And then you go—you get like sorta crazy with your patterns—you're like—(cymbal crashes appear, breaks follow). Right? And then you like step something like... scary? Maybe like, 'Ooh yeah, a freaked out child in the woods.' And then you do that again. You go like—(snare rush fades in again, more breaks follow). And that's pretty much it.

absolute banger wisdom, best reply on the thread