Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[foilman8805]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

hi19?

He'll probably refuse just like the last time he was asked.

I really can't think of anyone to be a judge in all honesty. Who were you guys thinking of to begin with, Tass?

[NekoGon]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

me lol

nominated

[TC_Halogen]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Hm...

Only three names come to mind for me: Patashu, behanjc, and bmah. Behan's sims are pretty good quality almost all of the time, well, I've played Patashu's sims in SM (not too many in FFR though). I've loved just about all bmah's sims too--but that one is more opinionated since I don't know if everyone pays attention to him.

[gnr61]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

i would judge
also might as well take this opportunity to get 2

[Zybanthia]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I've loved just about all bmah's sims too--but that one is more opinionated since I don't know if everyone pays attention to him.

I've actually enjoyed the majority of bmah's sims as well; of the three you listed, I'd probably vote bmah.

I'm just worried about the auto-accept policy if certain people become judges, hahaha.

[Patashu]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

do you understand how to understep a file in a consistent pleasing manner puppet?

cccp blah blah blah

[foilman8805]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I could tolerate bmah as a judge.

Would need to see more stuff from Patashu to say y/n.

behanjc...no. Never. I can see the criticisms from him now, "You didn't put enough jumps in and you missed about 25 32nd note hi-hats and a few 48ths too, gg nub. (3/10) [-]"

[gnr61]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

do you understand how to understep a file in a consistent pleasing manner puppet?

cccp blah blah blah

i think u and jx (him mostly lol) are the only ones here who have played my sm files hehe
and to answer your question, cccp blah blah blah

[stavie33]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

1. behan
2. bmah
3. EW
4. Patashu (nothing against you, I've just only seen two of your files, I'm sure you're more than qualified though)
5. gnr16 (CCCP blah blah blah)

[hi19hi19]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

not me haha i dont think you guys know the sheer number of crap files ive made... dont trust me heh

1. behan (probably going to refuse but who knows?)
2. EW
3. EW
4. EW
5. EW


edit 6. maybe that patashu guy

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

ok.... so out of the 97 files for this batch...

16 +d by both
23 +d by just blu (actually 30, but 7 of them were +. and 4.5 or less by jx, so I'm not testing them. also, 4 of them were + by blu and 4.5 or less by jx... so, sadly, I will be playing those.)
3 +d by just jx


another note... of the 19 files jx +d, 17 of them were +. the other 2 were files that jx submitted. not one file got higher than a 7/10.

blu rated 14 files as 8/10, 3 as 9/10, and 1 as 9.5/10 (both of jx's files were 8+). blu also rated a +. file "boring/10"... and other files jx/10, fun/10, cantspellthis/10, nubbin/10, lolanotherfilenamedrain/10, boring/9, skeletor/10, and wrongbpm/10.... more fun note: both files rated boring were by robertsona.


so, i guess i have to test 42 of the 97 files. damn you blu, once again. a small (large?) part of me will rejoice at your absence these next few months! until, of course, the next judge approves of 75% of the submitted files. and then i cry.

[Patashu]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

what does EW stand for aaa tell me

[stavie33]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

not me haha i dont think you guys know the sheer number of crap files ive made... dont trust me heh

1. behan (probably going to refuse but who knows?)
2. EW
3. EW
4. EW
5. EW


edit 6. maybe that patashu guy

yeah, I'm also shocked at how little people have nominated EW, I think he should be a judge next to Behan, personally, I haven't seen EW make a single bad file, ever...they're all perfectly synched, well stepped, and fun. And he's made some very easy files as well as very hard ones, so he's well rounded in every aspect except syncing weird files, which I haven't seen him do, and that's why behan, who's never, ever made a bad file IMO and has stepped many weird and tricky songs should be the number 1 pic for new judge

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

wow. glad there are so many responses in regards to the judge question. as far as the 1 hi19 fan... did we ever ask hi19 to judge? i sure hope not. as he has mentioned already himself.

as for who we've been discussing as a judge... you'll just have to wait a bit longer. but, glad to see you guys are fairly unified in who you think would be a good judge.



ps - behan and EW have been approached in the past to be judges.

and EW = ElectricWerewolf.

[foilman8805]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I think hi19 was brought up back in the day when you guys were looking for a judge after Rebirth quit. Sorry if I'm mistaken.

EW would be a decent judge, imo. Though I find his files hit and miss. Some I like, some I don't really like.