Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Traditionally, borderline files are rejected or queued conditionally...depends on the file.
edit: yeah, +.,+.,? almost makes it, but not quite
and I guess jimerax's point system eliminates the subjectivity on what I said above

And dunno what's up with files not fully judged by everyone. I guess you either have the remaining judge(s) to review those files or at the very least, make a decision upon the current judgment (although this isn't quite fair).
edit: with jimerax's point system, incomplete judgment is definitely not a fair thing if left as is

@jx: could you put some more info on the point system on the first page of the thread? You might notice that Tass' descriptions refer to a rating out of 5, which isn't on the same scale as yours.

[Patashu]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

the files that weren't judged by everyone were because alphabetical order is ambiguous. you can sort by:
1. directory name, counting or not counting punctuation
2. song name in simfile, counting or not counting punctuation
3. mp3 name or name as tagged in mp3, counting or not counting punctuation

in fact, I believe all four of those files I listed have 3 or more ratings if you look at all quarters

[who_cares973]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

looking at the notes from others in my group and it looks like i forgot to judge some files that i was suppose to add to our batch OOPS


brb judging

[who_cares973]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

and fixed

Lolituma BassHunter Remix: Agree with gdude so check his notes [+.]

Down: only real comment is i suggest layering in the kick 61.5 onward until the next section starts [+]

field of snow: tone down the hand and quad usage along with the jack usage and work on your pr also try halving the bpm in the beginning so it isnt just red everywhere and it'll be good. i remember giving you a pretty in depth review of this file prior to ffr going offline. dont know if you actually changed the file since though. [?]


haha just read the first couple lines of the batch review thread and oops guess i'll start pming my notes from now on

[pedolad]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Finally I got a damn file accepted.

[Silvuh]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Being the last in my group to finish, I thought I'd do this:

Floating Through Time: + + +? [13]
Greensleeves: + +. +. [13]
Grocery Escape Plan: +. +? + [12]
Directly Perfectly(wc) +. +. +? [11]
Dreamin' In The 80's: +. +. +? [11]
Eating Crow: +? +? + [11]
Extreme Dishwasher Race: +? +. +. [11]
Death Traveller: +. +. ? [10]
disco 80's: +. +. ? [10]
Experiment: +? + ? [10]
Lunar Dial: +? +? +? [9]
Directly Perfectly(E) < ? ? [8]
ESC: +? +? ? [8]
Hate: +? ? +? [8]
Gene Gadget Zone Act 1: - +. ? [7]
Holy War: ? ? +? [7]
for FFR (V2): ? ? ? [6]
Happy Guy Falls Off a Not-So-Happy Mountain: ? ? ? [6]
Dumpstream: +? - - [5]
Frühlingsrauchen: ? - ? [5]
Honey Cookie: +? - - [5]
Deco Stop: ? - - [4]
Dizzay: ? - - [4]
Epileptic Crisis: - ? - [4]
Field of Snow: - - - [3]
Hand Throw: - - - [3]

[Coolboyrulez0]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

So file score ≥ 10 = Acceptance? (Sorry, don't recall what it takes for a file to be accepted - it's been a while)
If so, I've got 1/2 in so far (Eating Crow, also if wc wouldnt be a nazi NaiNai would be in also )

[Dimentio]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I lose confidence that Rebirth will actually judge. Call me if you need me

[TC_Halogen]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I thought it was 13 out of 15...

EDIT: I love the variance between the three judges within my group, haha. At least we all have pretty nicely differing opinions.

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Updated with Silvuh's enormous notes.

I lose confidence that Rebirth will actually judge. Call me if you need me

I'm not even sure if Rebirth0 or NSane is even aware that they are supposed to be judging.

Can someone inquire if they're still interested...or even aware?

[Korygon]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Rebirth volunteered so he SHOULD know, and nsane is supposed to be the one running this so he REALLY should know

[TC_Halogen]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Oh jeez, I forgot to judge Lunar Dial - sorry about that. Will get to it tomorrow.

[AsphyxZero]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Sent a file !!

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I wasn't aware of this before, but we apparently have permission for Dj Aligator. Someone step Blow My Whistle Bitch mmm?

[Patashu]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

wowow parental advisory man !!