2019 September/October Set 3

[devonin]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

Yeah I definitely thing nothing is gained by grading these on a curve. It makes perfect sense to me that over time, submitted charts would creep up in quality.

[qrrbrbirbel]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

Met my personal goal of barely passing, so happy!

Thanks for the constructive feedback rebirth, I'll be sure to take my time on the last 2 bits of advice and resubmit soon!

[Reshiram]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

Rebirth gave me a 9 holy shit am I dreaming

It took me a few listens for those m30 minijacks but I definitely agree there. If that's the case I'm hearing a similar sound on m34 that might deserve minijacks (note 122.000-123.000 and note 138.000-139.000??) Also went ahead and changed the longjack on m49 to a pair of two-noters as suggested

[Rebirth0]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

On a side note I noticed a few missed jumps on 57.915s (4x repetitions) and 67.160s (2x repetitions). I believe those translate to m27 beat 1 and m31 beat 2.
I can add a jump at the start of the jacks at 103.739s (m48 beat 3) + repetitions as well.

I didn't even notice that but I agree with your take. Would be good to add stuff at those spots. Looks like they're mostly green notes. Jump at the beginning of some of those jacks are fine too.

As for the hands thing. It's not a huge concern and it is personal opinion of someone who hasn't done this in a long time. Even as is, this is a great file to play.

We chose to not layer some 32nd kicks in those stream sections to keep the difficulty curve nice and consistent and focus on the melodic (32nd) elements. Would prefer to keep it that way unless it's a hard reject.

I don't think any difficulty consistency would be lost in adding some 32nds. They're already all over the place. I can see the VERY SLIGHT difference in where you put the 32nds vs where you intentionally missed them. I can pass it as is, but I do think they should be added.

Rebirth gave me a 9 holy shit am I dreaming

It took me a few listens for those m30 minijacks but I definitely agree there. If that's the case I'm hearing a similar sound on m34 that might deserve minijacks (note 122.000-123.000 and note 138.000-139.000??) Also went ahead and changed the longjack on m49 to a pair of two-noters as suggested

I see what you're talking about with the part at m34 beat 3 (starting at 55.884). It is ok as is but I would not object if you wanted mini jacks there. It is technically correct to add them. Really I'm sure you could get away with adding more mini jacks all over the song but that might be a bit too much. Not sure how everyone feels about jacks nowadays.

[suicidaln00b]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

- I believe most if not all of the 24th streams/bursts are actually 32nds but maybe you watered them down for the sake of ease of play? I'm fine with it, but maybe if there is a hard file batch soon this could be held and "fixed" for that.

NAH mang i didnt even notice some of those were 32nds, also fixed

- Only thing I don't like is the 24th stream starting at m93. It's mostly in the music but the volume of the music doesn't justify the file to continue since the music is phasing out. Just add a yellow '12' after the blue at the start of m93 and it's good. Accepted if m93 stream is removed

i assume you mean m92
also oh dang i honestly like the "fuck your AAA" ending as is, but if i really must change it then i'd rather keep in the notes for the hi-hat thingy, the piano, and the last 5 notes going to the percussion (basically remove 24ths)
ending the song at m92 would be weird

[XelNya]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

Shotgun Senorita (XelNya) [9/10]
- The 32nd stream that ends in '212' at the beginning is weird. All of the other streams don't have that difficult one handed end to the bursts (for spread players). Consider changing for consistency.
- Extra 32nd at m80 beat 4? Doesn't need to be there
- Consider changing some patterns in the 8th note spot at m91-m93. You could get away with it with the way the music is.
- Accepted but consider the changes.

Did them all.

I sent them through the update feature? I hope that's about right.

[psychoangel691]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

Grabbing all updated files for the sets, for this set these are the updates I saw:

Accepted:
Coconut Adventure (suicidaln00b)
Identity Part 5 (Reshiram)
Shotgun Senorita (XelNya)

Please let me know if I missed anything

[psychoangel691]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

reviewed by TC_Halogen

Fast Fissure (Atomhead Remix) [choof] {Annwn}
Rating: 7.5/10 [+.]
- offset is way off (changed from -5.892 to -5.938)
- thankfully, that’s the worst thing about this chart
- very regimented and extremely strict structure, but for this song, it works nicely
- 36.795: change these patterns up a bit so they’re not directly identical with the opening; the overall jump/minijack motif can stay, just don’t make exactly the same as the opening again
- 1:09.259/1:09.580: that high-pitched distorted synth could use a bit more of an accent given that it coincides with a jump at 1:09.045 and is most likely the most audible/paid attention to sound in this particular section
- 1:10.652/etc: given your overall structure, these feel like missed opportunities to utilize mini-jacks (1:10.652/1:10.759, 1:10.973/1:11.080)
- 1:10.866: missing note
- spikes are a little nasty in this chart, but in my opinion not quite enough to push away
- tweak up the file a bit by improving some of the mini-jack placement
- good enough for queue imo; it actually plays really well and is quite enjoyable

[psychoangel691]

Re: 2019 September/October Set 3

Eiketsu he Tsureru
Ko Mu no Kamisama

have been moved to rejected, no re-submission made